Live updates: Trump impeachment inquiry | CNN Politics

The latest on the Trump impeachment inquiry

McKinley Yovanovitch SPLIT
Key lines from latest impeachment inquiry transcripts
2:27 • Source: CNN
McKinley Yovanovitch SPLIT
2:27

Where things stand now

  • Transcripts released: The House Intelligence Committee released transcripts from depositions with former US ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch and former State Department adviser Michael McKinley. Transcripts show that McKinley cited Yovanovitch’s removal and the use of ambassadors “to advance domestic political objectives” as reasons for his resignation last month.
  • Skipped testimony: Four White House officials — including John Eisenberg, deputy counsel to the President for national security affairs — were scheduled to testify today, but none of them showed up. An administration official said Eisenberg didn’t appear because of executive privilege while Robert Blair, Michael Ellis and Brian McCormack aren’t going to appear because they won’t be able to have an administration lawyer present.
  • Sign up for CNN’s Impeachment Watch newsletter here.

Updates

(57)

Our live coverage has ended, but you can scroll through the posts to read more or follow CNN’s Impeachment Tracker.

Trump makes a series of false claims at tonight's rally

President Trump made a series of false claims at his rally in Lexington, Kentucky, tonight.

Trump claimed, as he has several times, that President Barack Obama left him with 142 federal judges to appoint.

  • Facts First: According to Russell Wheeler, a visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution who tracks judicial appointments, there were 103 vacancies on district and appeals courts on Jan. 1, 2017, just before Trump took office, plus a vacancy on the Supreme Court.

Trump also said Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell passed “VA Choice and VA accountability for our amazing veterans.”

  • Facts First: The Choice bill, a bipartisan initiative led by Sens. Bernie Sanders and the late John McCain, was signed into law by Barack Obama in 2014. In 2018, Trump signed the VA Mission Act, which expanded and changed the program.

On China, Trump said “they’ve never given us 10 cents before.”

  • Facts First: The US government has been charging tariffs on imported Chinese goods for more than two centuries, and it took in billions from such tariffs long before Trump imposed his own. (As always, we’ll note it is US importers and consumers, not China, who have paid these tariffs.)

Trump claimed China “stole up to $500 billion of American dollars.” 

  • Facts First: The US has never had a $500 billion trade deficit with China.

Trump made three false claims about immigration and the border. He claimed “Democrats want open borders,” “the wall is being built,” and “we have 27,000 Mexican soldiers on our border.”

  • Facts First: Even 2020 Democratic presidential candidates who advocate the decriminalization of the act of illegally entering the country do not support completely unrestricted migration, as Trump suggests. Furthermore, no new miles of border wall had been built during Trump’s presidency as of Sept. 30. And the approximately 26,000 Mexican troops are split between the US border and Mexico’s southern border.

Like he did at his rally last Friday, Trump claimed he would “always protect patients with pre-existing conditions.”

  • Facts First: We usually don’t fact-check promises, but this one has already proved untrue. The Trump administration and congressional Republicans have repeatedly put forward bills and filed lawsuits that would weaken Obamacare’s protections for people with pre-existing conditions.

Trump wrongly claims he released a rough transcript of his Ukraine call after Schiff's account of the conversation

President Trump claimed tonight that he released a rough transcript of his July call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky after Rep. Adam Schiff, the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, made his supposed “parody” of the call.

Trump said Schiff “he made a horrible statement, it was a total lie and then I actually went and released the actual conversation.”

Facts First: Schiff made his comments about Trump’s call with Zelensky the day after Trump released the rough transcript, not before.

Trump goes after whistleblower at center of impeachment inquiry

President Trump speaks during a rally at Rupp Arena in Lexington, Kentucky, on Nov. 4.

President Trump continued to poke the whistleblower at the center of the impeachment inquiry during a rally in Kentucky tonight.

Trump reiterated that the whistleblower has been quiet since he released a rough transcript of his call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.

In recent days, Trump has escalated his attacks on the whistleblower, implying the person is politically motivated and urging reporters to disclose their identity. The whistleblower’s report has been corroborated by mounting on-the-record testimony from witnesses.

Trump rails against Democrats at Kentucky rally

President Trump gestures as he speaks during a rally at Rupp Arena in Lexington, Kentucky, on Nov. 4.

President Trump came out swinging at his rally tonight in support of Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin ahead of Tuesday’s gubernatorial election.

He went on to criticize Democrats, saying they “want to obliterate the rule of law… silence you online, confiscate your guns — you better be careful.”

Trump falsely claims Pelosi's district has especially significant pollution

President Trump, speaking at a rally in Kentucky tonight, said Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi should go back to her district to “get rid of the needles that are lying all over the street and all of the things that are washing into the ocean.”

Facts First: There is no evidence for Trump’s claim that Pelosi’s district, which includes San Francisco, has especially significant pollution, including needles, being sent into the ocean through storm sewers.

San Francisco Mayor London Breed called Trump’s claims “ridiculous,” saying in a statement that the city’s sewer system “ensures that all debris that flow into storm drains are filtered out at the city’s wastewater treatment plants.”

Trump holds campaign rally in Kentucky tonight

President Trump departs the White House in Washington, DC, on Nov. 4 for a campaign rally in Kentucky.

President Trump will hold a rally in Lexington, Kentucky, tonight ahead of Tuesday’s election.

Republican Gov. Matt Bevin, who was elected in 2015, is running for reelection against the state’s attorney general, Democrat Andy Beshear.

Trump, who has endorsed Bevin, is looking to encourage voters to turn out for the Republican candidate.

Trump won Kentucky by nearly 30 points in 2016, but in 2015, Bevin’s victory came within 10 points of his opponent.

You can watch Trump’s rally live in the video player above or watch it here.

Ex-Pompeo adviser contradicts former boss in testimony

Michael McKinley, former senior adviser to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, directly contradicted public comments made by the top US diplomat when he testified under oath last month as part of the impeachment inquiry into President Trump.

McKinley, who resigned amid the Ukraine controversy, raised concerns about former US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch’s removal, which was pushed by Trump’s personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, and has become a central part of the inquiry, according to a transcript of that testimony released Monday.

While Pompeo told ABC News last month that McKinley never raised the idea of issuing a statement of support for Yovonovitch, McKinley directly contradicted that statement while under oath, telling lawmakers he mentioned it on three separate occasions.

Specifically, McKinley who testified behind closed doors on Oct. 16, said that he raised the Yovanovitch matter with Pompeo three times and proposed releasing a statement of support for the former diplomat, who was abruptly recalled from her post, but did not receive a response from the secretary of state, including when he told Pompeo he was leaving the department.

McKinley told lawmakers that he raised the issue on two other occasions, including during a phone call to discuss his resignation.

What Pompeo said: In the ABC News after McKinley’s testimony, the secretary of state said: “From the time that Ambassador Yovanovitch departed Ukraine until the time that (McKinley) came to tell me that he was departing, I never heard him say a single thing about his concerns with respect to the decision that was made,” Pompeo said of McKinley. “Not once … did Ambassador McKinley say something to me during that entire time period.”

Keep reading here.

Trump suggests whistleblower "gave a lot of false information"

President Trump said today that the whistleblower gave “a lot of false information” and their report was “very wrong,” despite mounting on-the-record testimony from witnesses corroborating the whistleblower’s account.

In recent days, Trump has escalated his attacks on the whistleblower at the center of the impeachment inquiry, implying the person is politically motivated and urging reporters to disclose their identity. Today, Trump questioned the whereabouts of the whistleblower, as well as a second whistleblower and an informant.

“The whistleblower seems to have disappeared and I also wonder what happened to the second whistleblower, and what happened to the informant?” he asked.

Trump has been falsely claiming the whistleblower complaint has been debunked. According to a CNN analysis, the overwhelming majority of allegations in the complaint have been corroborated by official government documents, Trump’s public statements, and news reporting. Trump has relied on lies and falsehoods to undermine the complaint.

Podcast: Congress got stood up, but the transcripts arrived

In the latest episode of “The Daily DC: Impeachment Watch” podcast, CNN Political Director David Chalian looks at:

  • The week ahead in impeachment news  
  • President Trump’s weekend barrage of his messaging and defense against potential impeachment
  • Kellyanne Conway’s refusal to say there wasn’t a quid pro quo
  • The President’s effort to unmask the whistleblower, which is precisely at odds with the purpose of whistleblower protection law
  • The transcripts from interviews with former US ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch and former State Department adviser Michael McKinley
  • Fox News host Sean Hannity’s bizarre role in getting Yovanovitch fired  

Chalian is joined today by Zach Wolf, CNN’s senior writer and publisher of Impeachment Watch Tracker, and Shan Wu, CNN legal analyst and former federal prosecutor.

Listen to the podcast here.

Yovanovitch said top State Department officials reached out to Fox News' Sean Hannity for Ukraine information

In the scramble this spring to figure out why then-US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch was being recalled from Kiev, the highest levels of the State Department turned to Fox News host Sean Hannity for information, according to Yovanovitch’s testimony.

In her closed-door deposition, Yovanovitch said she heard that Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, or his senior aides, were reaching out to Hannity to figure out why he was criticizing her and calling for her removal from Ukraine. (Yovanovitch was the target of repeated attacks by Hannity, Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani and Donald Trump Jr., the President’s son.)

She testified:

Yovanovitch continued, “And I understand that that call was made. I don’t know whether it was the Secretary or somebody else in his inner circle.”

She explained that things “simmered down” for a bit after that phone call, and that the attacks against her lulled before later reaching a fever pitch later on with her removal.

More context here: Hannity and Fox News are mentioned at least dozen times in the 317-page transcript. He is an incredible influential voice in Trump’s orbit, acting as an informal adviser to the President and routinely using his TV platform to push pro-Trump talking points and conspiracy theories. 

Throughout Yovanovitch’s deposition, she explained how career State Department officials struggled to square official US policy with the positions being floated by Trump’s allies in conservative media, including Hannity, and John Solomon’s controversial columns in The Hill. 

McKinley believed conduct of Ukraine policy by some officials hurt integrity of the State Department

Former State Department adviser Michael McKinley said he believed that the conduct of US policy toward Ukraine by some State Department officials was hurting the integrity of the Department’s diplomatic work.

McKinley said his “impression” was that the “overwhelming majority” would agree with his assessment.

Yovanovitch testifies Ukrainian official told US embassy that Trump may have called into Giuliani meeting

Former US ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch testified that a Ukrainian official told the US embassy that President Trump may have joined a meeting between Rudy Giuliani and then-Ukrainian Prosecutor General Yuriy Lutsenko by phone. 

She said that Deputy Prosecutor General Yevhen Yenin told Charges D’affaires in Kiev at the time Joseph Pennington about the rumor and that she heard it from Pennington. It was her understanding that Yenin had heard it from Lutsenko.

“So you’re saying was that Mr. Lutsenko had told him that the President had phoned into their meeting?” she was asked.

 “Uh-huh,” she replied.

 “Is that a yes?” she was asked.

 “That’s a yes,” she said. 

We're still reading the transcripts. Here are the key lines so far.

The House Intelligence Committee released transcripts from interviews with two US officials, which were conducted as part of the impeachment inquiry into President Trump.

The transcripts were from depositions with former US ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch and former State Department adviser Michael McKinley.

We’re still going through the documents, and we’ll keep posting highlights here. So far, here are some of the key lines:

Yovanovitch’s testimony

  • She said a Ukrainian official warned her to “watch my back” as Trump associates worked to undermine her and have her removed.
  • A Ukrainian official also told Yovanovitch that he believed it “dangerous” to engage with Trump’s personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani “because of his concerns about what they were doing.” 
  • Yovanovitch said she felt threatened after Trump used her name on the July 25 phone call to the Ukrainian president.
  • Yovanovitch said Giuliani’s shadow diplomacy “cut the ground out from underneath us” at the US embassy and hampered her efforts to represent the US as the senior-most diplomat in Ukraine.
  • She said it was “not good policy” and not in the interests of the United States to get the State Departments involved in Trump and Giuliani’s efforts to solicit political help from the Ukrainian government.

McKinley’s testimony

  • McKinley testified that he never had any discussions with anyone at the State Department about Giuliani.
  • McKinley said he raised the idea of sending a statement of support for former US ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch three separate times with Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and never received a substantive response from him. 
  • McKinley told lawmakers that he spoke with a fellow ambassador about what McKinley believed sounded like “bullying tactics” within the State Department toward officials who might comply with the impeachment investigation.
  • He testified that he chose to resign because in part because of what he saw as the use of ambassadors “to advance domestic political objectives.”
  • McKinley said he “was ‘disturbed’ by the implication that foreign governments were being approached to procure negative information on political opponents.”

Yovanovitch said former Ukrainian prosecutor "lied" about coming to the US to meet with Giuliani

In her testimony, former US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch defended the decision to deny the former Ukrainian prosecutor general Viktor Shokin a visa to the US and suggested she was blindsided by Rudy Giuliani going to the White House and senior State Department officials to lobby on his behalf. 

Yovanovitch said she was alerted that “the embassy had received a visa application for a tourist visa from Mr. Shokin, the previous prosecutor general. And he said that he was coming to visit his children, who live in the United States. And so, the consular folks, you know, got the application, recognized the name, and believed that he was ineligible for a visa, based on his, you know, known corrupt activities.”

She said that it was her understanding that the embassy gave Shokin either a “formal hard refusal or what we call a 221G, which is an administrative refusal, asking for more information.”

Yovanovitch said she alerted George Kent, who notified then Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs A. Wess Mitchell about Shokin’s visa denial.

“And when you know, of course, when the calls came from Mr. Giuliani to the White House and to the Assistant Secretary for Consular Affairs, they got in touch with the European Bureau, and Mr. Mitchell, you know, held firm. I mean, it was a consular decision. The consular folks felt that they had made the right decision. And, you know, there was the added issue that, you know, basically the notorious reputation of Mr. Shokin,” she said.

“And, frankly, at the end of the day, he lied on his visa application,” Yovanovitch added, noting that he had said on his application he was visiting family when he was really visiting Giuliani.

Trump says Nationals' win is all America could talk about — "that and impeachment"

Catcher Kurt Suzuki wears a "Make America Great Again" hat as he is hugged by President Trump as he welcomes the 2019 World Series Champions, the Washington Nationals, to the White House

As key witness testimony in the impeachment inquiry rocks Washington, President Trump welcomed the Washington Nationals, this year’s World Series Champions, to the White House.

“The last time Washington, DC, was home to the World Series champs, the President was a man by the name of Calvin Coolidge,” Trump said, predicting that this would be the first championship “of many.”

Trump said America fell in love with Nationals baseball this season, adding that it was was “all they could talk about.”

The President said he has proclaimed today Washington Nationals Day, as he congratulated the team. A military band played “We are the Champions” as the President and First Lady departed. 

Not every member of the Nationals attended the event. In addition to Sean Doolittle declining the invitation, it appears Anthony Rendon, Victor Robles, Wander Suero, Javy Guerra, Joe Ross, Wilmer Difo and Michael A. Taylor also did not come to the White House today.  

Watch here:

Yovanovitch transcript shows Republican efforts to question impeachment inquiry

The transcript of Marie Yovanovitch’s testimony makes clear Republican efforts to question the impeachment effort’s procedures, even as GOP members were given equal time to question the former US ambassador to Ukraine.

Before the questioning even began, Republicans criticized the rules surrounding the inquiry and suggested it should be led by another committee. Rep. Jim Jordan, a Trump ally, said the President and Republicans should be able to see all the evidence and present their own evidence “bearing on the credibility” of witnesses. The Ohio Republican also said President Trump should be able to respond to the testimony.

The Republicans went back-and-forth with House Intelligence Committee chairman Adam Schiff over the rules before the questioning began. 

Later, the Republicans interjected when it became known that Yovanovitch’s opening statement had been obtained by the media, which they repeatedly attempted to question her about. Her lawyer sought to block those questions, though she eventually responded to an inquiry on whether she thought her opening statement should be provided to the press. 

Later, during their time to question Yovanovitch, the Republicans asked about a conversation she had with George Kent, a State Department official, about Trump’s July 25 phone call with Zelensky after she was recalled from her post.

Rep. Mark Meadows, a Republican from South Carolina, also asked Yovanovitch why she was called “Masha,” to which she replied that it’s a common Russian nickname. 

Yovanovitch: Ukrainian official told me to "watch my back" after Giuliani efforts

In her deposition, former US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch said she was warned by a senior Ukrainian official that she needed to watch her back as Trump associates worked to undermine her and have her removed.

Asked about her conversations with Ukrainian officials about Rudy Giuliani, Yovanovitch said she recalled a February 2019 conversation with one official who was “very concerned” about Giuliani’s efforts along with his associates Lev Parnas and Igor Fruman.

Yovanovitch was told she needed to come back home out of concerns for her "security"

Former US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch fought to stay in Ukraine, but was told she had to be “on the next plane home” out of concerns for her “security.” 

Here’s how Yovanovitch explained the situation:

Yovanovitch recounted Volker telling her Giuliani backlash against her would "blow over" 

Former US Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch said former special envoy for Ukraine Kurt Volker told her the backlash against her would “blow over,” and that she did not recall discussing Rudy Giuliani’s activities in Ukraine with Volker.

READ MORE

READ MORE