Live updates: The latest on the Trump impeachment inquiry | CNN Politics

The latest on the Trump impeachment inquiry

U.S. President Donald Trump walks toward Marine One while departing for Pittsburgh to speak at the annual Shale Insight Conference, on October 23.
Why the 'quid pro quo' defense may not matter
1:51 • Source: CNN
U.S. President Donald Trump walks toward Marine One while departing for Pittsburgh to speak at the annual Shale Insight Conference, on October 23.
1:51

Where things stand now

  • The latest: Sen. Lindsey Graham introduced a resolution critical of the House impeachment process. Only three GOP senators haven’t signed on to support the resolution, which calls on the House to hold a vote to initiate a formal inquiry. 
  • New ruling: A federal judge gave a legal endorsement to the impeachment probe into President Trump and ordered the Justice Department to release grand jury information redacted from the Mueller report.
  • Possible public hearings: Democrats plan on holding public hearings with some witnesses who have been deposed. The hearings could begin in mid-November or after Thanksgiving depending on the witnesses.
  • Sign up for CNN’s Impeachment Watch newsletter here.
  • Our live coverage has ended, but you can scroll through the posts to read more.
38 Posts

Trump attacks impeachment inquiry in tweets

President Trump mischaracterized why congressional testimony from an anonymous whistleblower is growing unlikely and attacked the House impeachment inquiry in a series of tweets tonight.

The attorneys for the whistleblower who lodged a complaint with the intelligence community inspector general related to Trump’s July 25 phone call with Ukraine’s President wrote in a Washington Post op-ed today that there is no need for their client to testify in person, even behind closed doors.  

Andrew Bakaj and Mark Zaid argue that their client’s anonymity needs to be protected and say he has no additional information to offer about the call, writing: “Because our client has no additional information about the president’s call, there is no justification for exposing their identity and all the risks that would follow.” 

In a separate tweet, Trump attack the impeachment process, calling it a scam.

The President also floated the idea of suing Democratic Rep. Adam Schiff. Trump has brought this up numerous times.

Pelosi says court ruling is "another blow to President Trump’s attempt to put himself above the law"

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi called today’s court ruling ordering the Department of Justice to release grand jury information redacted from special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation to Congress “another blow to President Trump’s attempt to put himself above the law.” 

Pelosi noted that the federal judge wrote, “Tipping the scale even further toward disclosure is the public’s interest in a diligent and thorough investigation into, and in a final determination about, potentially impeachable conduct by the President described in the Mueller report.” 

She continued: “The court challenges the administration’s unprecedented, blanket defiance of Congress’s oversight.”

Rudy Giuliani talks money and Bidens in dual accidental phone calls to reporter

Rudy Giuliani, President Trump’s personal lawyer, left two apparently unintended voicemails on a reporter’s phone this fall in which he discussed his need for hundreds of thousands of dollars and disparaged the Biden family, NBC reported on today.

The unwitting calls and messages from Giuliani, colloquially called “buttdials,” come as sources tell CNN that Giuliani has been approaching defense attorneys for possible representation following escalating reports regarding a federal investigation into his dealings in Ukraine.

“Tomorrow, I’ve got to get you on Bahrain. You’ve got to call,” Giuliani tells an unidentified associate in an Oct. 16 voicemail posted by NBC.

“The problem is we need some money,” Giuliani later adds when referencing a “Robert” who the unidentified associate said was in Turkey, pausing for several seconds before specifying, “We need a few hundred thousand.”

Giuliani told CNN’s Dana Bash today that the voicemail is “helpful because it shows that I don’t do anything dishonest,” saying it was completely unrelated to anything in Ukraine but declined to specify to what it was related.

“The $200,000 is for another project in another country,” Giuliani said. He called the project a “non-legal security matter” completely unrelated to anything related to Ukraine or Trump, but declined to specify what it was related to.

Giuliani said that the call pertained to a “change in personnel on a different project” that “will require an additional charge for the client.”

Giuliani has some previous ties to Bahrain, a key ally of Saudi Arabia. His former massive law firm Bracewell Giuliani previously worked on financial deals for Bahrain.

Keep reading here.

Mike Pompeo endorses work of Ukraine diplomat dismissed by Trump as "never Trumper"

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo seemed to voice subdued approval of the work of the top US diplomat in Ukraine whose testimony undermined the administration claims that President Trump had not pushed for investigations into his political rivals in exchange for US aid.

Pompeo said he and Bill Taylor, the charge d’affaires in Kiev, are “in full accord” on US policy there, but did not specifically address a question about his confidence in the diplomat himself.

Pompeo, conducting interviews over a two-day visit in Kansas, has been dismissive and evasive of questions surrounding the House Democratic impeachment probe, despite his department’s increasing entrenchment in that inquiry.

He sought to downplay the impeachment inquiry as Beltway “noise” in a series of interviews in Wichita, Kansas, on Thursday and Friday — just days after Taylor presented damning testimony related to a quid pro quo underlying presidential lawyer Rudy Giuliani’s efforts in Ukraine.

Some background: In his closed-door deposition Tuesday, Taylor said he had been told that “everything” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky wanted, including a White House meeting and military aid to the country, would be held up until he publicly announced the launch of investigations sought by Trump.

GOP challenger Mark Sanford says he supports censuring Trump

Mark Sanford, Republican presidential challenger and former South Carolina congressman, told CNN he supports censuring President Trump over impeaching him.

He went on to say that the impeachment process “is fraught with a number of different perils, both for our Republic, and debate in this republic and for the Democratic party and ultimately for what comes next in the world of politics.”

Sanford said he thinks the House will likely vote to impeach Trump and the Senate will acquit the President.

Watch the moment:

Podcast: Increasingly unlikely whistleblower will be made to testify

In today’s latest episode of “The Daily DC: Impeachment Watch” podcast, CNN Political Director David Chalian covers:

  • How Attorney General William Barr’s probe into the intelligence and origins of the 2016 Trump-Russia investigation is now a criminal probe
  • Sen. Lindsey Graham and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s proposed resolution to slam the impeachment process and the Republicans who have not supported it yet
  • The GOP response plan to all things impeachment
  • Subpoenas issued to three Trump administration officials

Chalian is joined by CNN national security reporter Jeremy Herb and Alice Stewart, a CNN political commentator and Republican strategist.

Listen to the podcast here.

Justice Department says it's reviewing court ruling on Mueller grand jury materials

The Department Justice said it is reviewing a federal court decision that it must release grand jury information redacted from the Mueller report to the House Judiciary Committee by Oct. 30.

“We are reviewing the decision,” a spokesperson said.

About the decision: The ruling is a blow to the Trump administration’s claims that the House is not conducting a valid impeachment inquiry since there’s been no formal vote to authorize the probe.

In a lengthy opinion, Chief Judge Beryl Howell of the US District Court in Washington, DC, said the House clearly is conducting an impeachment inquiry.

“(A)n impeachment trial is an exercise of judicial power,” Howell wrote. “Contrary to (the Justice Department’s) position — and as historical practice, the Federalist Papers, the text of the Constitution, and Supreme Court precedent all make clear — impeachment trials are judicial in nature and constitute judicial proceedings.”

Catch up: 6 key developments in the impeachment inquiry today

Here are the latest developments in the House impeachment inquiry into President Trump:

  • Kellyanne Conway speaks: Asked about top Ukraine diplomat Bill Taylor’s testimony and his laying out of a quid pro quo, Conway told reporters today, “That’s one person’s testimony. There’s been other testimony. I believe that Ambassador Sondland… made very clear in a text to Ambassador Taylor that was not the President’s intent.”
  • Possible new hire: The White House is eyeing former Treasury Department spokesman Tony Sayegh to lead impeachment messaging efforts, three sources familiar with the discussions said. While the President has opposed a war room effort, several of his top aides are increasingly recognizing the need to bolster the White House’s messaging operations as Democrats march toward impeachment. Trump has not yet signed off on Sayegh.
  • Trump’s remarks: Asked whether he would apologize for referring to the impeachment inquiry as a “lynching,” Trump pointed the finger at Democrats instead, and said the term has “been used many times” despite its association with the extrajudicial killings of African Americans.
  • Deposition in discussion: Lawyers for former national security adviser John Bolton have had talks with the impeachment inquiry committees about a possible deposition, according to a source familiar. Taylor, the diplomat, told Congress that Bolton had expressed concerns about a call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, according to Taylor’s opening statement.
  • Subpoenas issued: House Democratic impeachment investigators have issued subpoenas to three Trump administration officials — acting Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought, OMB’s Associate Director of National Security Programs Michael Duffey and State Department Counselor Ulrich Brechbuhl.
  • A new ruling: A federal judge today ordered the Justice Department to release grand jury information redacted from the Mueller report to the House Judiciary Committee by Oct. 30. Chief Judge Beryl Howell noted that the House Judiciary Committee says “it needs the material to conduct a fair impeachment investigation based on all relevant facts.” She then declared, “Impeachment based on anything less than all relevant evidence would compromise the public’s faith in the process.”

Appeals court asks House to reply to Trump request for rehearing in tax case

A federal appeals court on Friday asked the House to respond to President Trump’s request to rehear a case concerning a subpoena to his longtime accounting firm. 

The request from the DC Circuit Court of Appeals suggests a larger panel of judges on the court is at least interested in whether it should rehear the case. It also could potentially delay Supreme Court review. 

What’s this all about: Trump has asked the DC Circuit Court of Appeals to rehear his attempt to stop a subpoena of his accounting firm, this time with the President asking the full appellate court to reconsider his case.

Trump lost his attempt to stop the House subpoena of accounting firm Mazars USA before a trial-level judge and 2-1 before an appellate panel. The courts so far have shot down Trump’s attempts to impede Congress’ subpoena power.

The subpoena of Mazars, still halted in the appeals process, is one of several attempts by the House to dig up more financial records of Trump’s. This subpoena was for eight years of documents held by his accounting firm.

Judge says House impeachment inquiry justifies disclosing Mueller grand jury material

In a lengthy opinion, Chief Judge for the DC District Court Beryl Howell found in favor of the House’s arguments, writing that the House impeachment inquiry is a judicial proceeding, and that “to avoid a possible injustice in the impeachment inquiry, that this need for disclosure is greater than the need for continued secrecy.” 

Howell further writes, “The need for continued secrecy is minimal and thus easily outweighed” by the committee’s “compelling need for the material.” She adds, “Tipping the scale even further toward disclosure is the public’s interest in a diligent and thorough investigation into, and in a final determination about, potentially impeachable conduct by the President described in the Mueller Report.”

The ruling is significant because the Trump administration has argued that such material should not be turned over because it says the House is not conducting a valid impeachment inquiry since there’s been no vote to authorize the probe. 

But Howell sided with Democrats and said clearly that the House is conducting an impeachment inquiry.

“This stance, in service of the obvious goal of blocking Congress from accessing grand jury material for any purpose, overlooks that an impeachment trial is an exercise of judicial power,” Howell said.

Howell noted that the House Judiciary Committee says “it needs the material to conduct a fair impeachment investigation based on all relevant facts.” She then declared, “Impeachment based on anything less than all relevant evidence would compromise the public’s faith in the process.”

CNN’s Joan Biskupic contributed to this report.

What to expect in the impeachment inquiry next week

Lawmakers on Capitol Hill have lined up numerous depositions starting Saturday in the ongoing impeachment inquiry into President Trump.

Check out the tentative schedule below and follow along with CNN’s impeachment tracker here:

  • Saturday, 11 a.m.: Philip Reeker, a career foreign service officer now serving as the acting assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs
  • Monday, 9:30 a.m.: Charles Kupperman, the former deputy national security adviser
  • Tuesday, 9:30 a.m.: Alexander Vindman, the White House National Security Council’s top expert on Ukraine
  • Wednesday, 9:30 a.m.: Kathryn Wheelbarger, acting assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security
  • Thursday, 8 a.m.: Tim Morrison, a top Russia and Europe adviser on President Trump’s National Security Council

Trump compares impeachment inquiry to the black experience with criminal justice

Speaking at the historically black Benedict College in South Carolina, President Trump seemingly likened the impeachment inquiry — which he views as unfair — to the unfair treatment African Americans have faced at the hands of the criminal justice system.

Describing his “own experience” with unfair treatment, Trump said he is now facing “an investigation in search of a crime.”

“In America you are innocent until proven guilty,” Trump added.

It was the second time in a speech ostensibly about criminal justice reform that Trump veered off script to bring up impeachment, something clearly on his mind.

Judge orders DOJ to release redacted Mueller grand jury information to House

A federal judge today ordered the Justice Department to release grand jury information redacted from the Mueller report to the House Judiciary Committee by Oct. 30.

The committee had gone to court seeking information in the Mueller report that is redacted because it came from secret grand jury proceedings. The committee had argued that it needs information from the secret grand jury used in former special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation to help in its current impeachment inquiry of President Donald Trump.

Trump touts Senate resolution condemning impeachment process at HBCU event

Speaking at historically black Benedict College ostensibly about criminal justice reform, President Trump touted the number of Republican senators who have signed onto a resolution condemning the House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.

Trump asked Sen. Lindsey Graham, who is spearheading the resolution and was in the room at the HBCU, if he knew that “50 out of 53” GOP senators had agreed to support the measure. In fact, Graham had announced it on Twitter earlier in the day. 

The President’s comments come as Graham promotes the resolution condemning the closed-door nature of the impeachment process and demanding the President get “due process,” a defense echoed increasingly by the White House.

Only three GOP senators haven't signed on to support Graham's impeachment resolution

Sen. Lindsey Graham is tweeting out the names of the co-sponsors of his impeachment resolution — which is now up to 50 GOP senators.

His list now includes Sens. Mike Enzi, of Wyoming, Lamar Alexander, of Tennessee, Cory Gardner, of Colorado, and Johnny Isakson, of Georgia, as co-sponsors. Isakson’s office had also confirmed to CNN that he had agreed to sign on. CNN has reached out to Alexander and Enzi.

That leaves Utah’s Mitt Romney, Susan Collins, of Maine, and Lisa Murkowski, of Alaska, as the Republicans who have not co-sponsored. Romney, through a spokesperson said that the senator “would take a look at it, and that he’d like to see a vote in the House and a more open process.”

CNN has not received a response from Collins’ or Murkowski’s offices after multiple requests for comment.

On Thursday, Graham introduced a resolution critical of the House impeachment process. The resolution calls on the House to hold a vote to initiate a formal inquiry. 

Here’s Graham tweeting this afternoon to show that he’s up to 50 co-sponsors:

Attorneys suggest no need for whistleblower to testify

Attorneys for the whistleblower who lodged a complaint related to President Trump’s July 25 call with Ukraine’s president suggest in a Washington Post op-ed that there is no need for the whistleblower to testify.   

Andrew Bakaj and Mark Zaid argue their client’s anonymity needs to be protected, and say he has no additional information to offer about the call, writing “Because our client has no additional information about the President’s call, there is no justification for exposing their identity and all the risks that would follow.”

Today’s op-ed follows a letter Bakaj sent earlier this month to leaders of the Senate intelligence committee in which they say an in-person meeting with committee staff is a “non-starter,” citing the need to protect the whistleblower’s safety.

Trump doesn't apologize for referring to impeachment inquiry as "lynching"

President Trump, when asked whether he would apologize for referring to the impeachment inquiry as a “lynching,” pointed the finger at Democrats instead, and said the term has “been used many times” despite its association with the extrajudicial killings of African Americans.

Notably, Trump made the remarks as he departed the White House for Benedict College, which is a historically black college.

Some background: On Tuesday, Trump called the House’ impeachment inquiry a “lynching,” in a tweet, saying “so some day, if a Democrat becomes President and the Republicans win the House, even by a tiny margin, they can impeach the President, without due process or fairness or any legal rights. All Republicans must remember what they are witnessing here - a lynching. But we will WIN!” 

Trump has repeatedly railed against the probe, calling it a “witch hunt” and a “fraud,” but Tuesday marks his first use of the term “lynching,” which is associated with a period of horrific racial violence in the United States, in regard to the inquiry. Following Emancipation and the Civil War, killings, often carried out in public settings, known as lynchings, terrorized newly freed black Americans. Thousands of citizens were killed this way.

Trump administration officials subpoenaed in impeachment inquiry

House Democratic impeachment investigators have issued subpoenas to three Trump administration officials whose testimony was previously scheduled, in a sign the Democrats are trying to compel testimony from Trump officials who are apparently reluctant to appear.

The committees said subpoenas have been issued to acting Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought, OMB’s Associate Director of National Security Programs Michael Duffey and State Department Counselor Ulrich Brechbuhl.

The subpoenas call for Duffey to appear on Nov. 5 and Vought and Brechbuhl to testify on Nov. 6.

What’s this all about: The committees leading the Democratic impeachment inquiry — Intelligence, Foreign Affairs and Oversight — have issued subpoenas to current State Department and Pentagon officials the morning of their testimony, in an effort to combat the Trump administration directing officials not to participate. But these appear to be the first subpoenas that would seek testimony from officials who were unwilling to testify when they had been initially scheduled.

It’s not clear whether the subpoenas will prompt any of the three officials to participate. All had been scheduled for depositions earlier this month that were then removed from the deposition calendar.

More context: Both OMB and the State Department — in addition to other federal agencies and the White House — have already failed to comply with House subpoenas from the impeachment inquiry for documents.

Vought tweeted on Monday that he and Duffey would not participate in their depositions that had been scheduled for this week. “As the White House letter made clear two weeks ago, OMB officials - myself and Mike Duffey - will not be complying with deposition requests this week,” Vought tweeted.

Trump confident he has Senate votes on impeachment: “Only for one reason, I did nothing wrong"

President Trump, when asked if he was confident he had the votes in the Senate if impeachment moves there, said: “only for one reason, I did nothing wrong.”

Trump then continued many of his familiar claims that the impeachment inquiry is a “hoax”.

Trump then started his gripes against “Never Trumpers” saying they are “more vicious than a failed Obama candidate or a failed Clinton candidate.”

“I’m not a fan of the Never Trumpers. We do have Never Trumpers — I’m not a fan. I think they’re bad people. Some have recovered, OK? They went through I guess a recovery program. It’s called, they learned how to win through me. But others haven’t. I’m not a fan of Never Trumpers, and I never will be,” the President said.

Trump says he's not concerned about criminal investigation into Rudy Giuliani

President Trump praised his attorney Rudy Giuliani as a “great gentleman” and a “great crimefighter.”

When asked whether he is concerned about the federal investigation into Giuliani, Trump said, “I don’t think so because I think Rudy is a great gentleman. He’s been a great crimefighter.”

“He looks for corruption everywhere he goes,” Trump claimed of the former New York City mayor.

Trump also called Giuliani the “greatest mayor in the history of New York” and called him “one of the greatest crimefighters and corruption-fighters.”

Federal investigators are probing whether Giuliani violated federal lobbying laws in his dealings with Ukraine after two of his associates in Ukraine matters were arrested.

GO DEEPER

GO DEEPER

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app on Google Play.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from Google Play.

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.