May 10, 2024 Israel-Hamas war | CNN

May 10, 2024 Israel-Hamas war

Israel Ambassador Gilad Menashe Erdan digivid
Israeli ambassador shreds UN document in angry speech
0:54 • Source: CNN
Israel Ambassador Gilad Menashe Erdan digivid
0:54

What we covered here

  • The Biden administration said Friday it is “reasonable to assess” that US weapons have been used by Israeli forces in Gaza in ways that are inconsistent with international humanitarian law – but the highly anticipated report stopped short of officially saying Israel violated the law.
  • Also on Friday, the White House said a CNN report on alleged systematic abuse at an Israeli prison was “deeply concerning” and that the US is reaching out to Israeli officials for answers. CNN spoke to three Israeli whistleblowers who revealed how prisoners are blindfolded, handcuffed and forced to wear diapers. 
  • Elsewhere, the UN General Assembly passed a resolution calling on the Security Council to reconsider Palestinian membership in the UN, a significant but ultimately symbolic move that the US is expected to veto.
  • Hamas on Friday said Israel’s rejection of a ceasefire plan submitted by mediators at negotiations in Cairo sent hostage release talks back to “square one.” 
35 Posts

There's been no aid to Gaza from the southern crossings in 3 days, World Food Programme says

Palestinians line up for food distribution in Deir al Balah, Gaza, Friday, May 10.

It’s been three days since humanitarian aid has gone through the southern crossings of the Gaza Strip, according to a post on X from the United Nation’s World Food Programme (WFP).

Only one bakery is functioning in Rafah, a city where some 1.4 million Palestinians are displaced and the Israeli military is advancing ahead of a possible ground invasion.

US report investigates whether Israel violated international law in Gaza. Here's what to know

A man snaps pictures from a rooftop as thick, black smoke rises from a fire in a building caused by Israeli bombardment in Rafah on May 10.

Thousands are fleeing the southern city of Rafah as the Israeli military steps up its operations, despite a warning from US President Joe Biden that a major Israeli offensive in the city of Rafah would result in a shut-off to some US weapons.

A new US report transmitted to Capitol Hill on Friday also sharply criticized the toll of Israel’s military campaign and the use of American weapons.

It all comes as ceasefire talks ended in Egypt with no deal after Israel rejected a plan submitted by mediators earlier this week.

Here are the key headlines:

The New US report:

  • The Biden administration said in a new report that it is “reasonable to assess” that US weapons have been used by Israeli forces in Gaza in ways that are inconsistent with international humanitarian law, but stopped short of officially saying Israel violated the law.
  • The report, which covers the period from the outbreak of the war with Hamas on October 7 to late April, did not find that Israel has withheld humanitarian aid to Gaza in violation of US law.
  • Biden is also facing bipartisan blowback over his ultimatum about Rafah to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Some Democratic lawmakers requested a briefing from the White House and one Republican opened a probe into Biden’s handling of Israel aid.

Rafah military operations:

  • Israel’s security cabinet approved an “expansion of the area of operation” in Rafah late Thursday, an Israeli official said. The approval is a way for the cabinet to express its support but is not an indication of imminent expansion of military operations there.
  • The White House said it sees no indication of a “large-scale invasion,” but the Biden administration is watching the situation closely and “with concern.” 
  • The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) estimates nearly 110,000 people have fled Rafah since Monday after the Israeli military issued an evacuation order for parts of the city. Some of those people have arrived in Khan Younis only to find it “completely destroyed,” with dire living conditions.
  • UN chief Antonio Guterres warned on Friday that a massive ground attack in Rafah would lead to an “epic humanitarian disaster.” The streets of central and eastern Rafah are empty and some food vendors say they don’t know where to go next.

Ongoing ceasefire and hostage release negotiations:

  • Hamas militants said Israel’s rejection of a ceasefire plan submitted by mediators at negotiations in Cairo sent hostage release talks back to “square one.” It accused Netanyahu of hindering the ceasefire talks to use negotiations as a cover to attack Rafah.
  • It comes one day after Israeli and Hamas negotiating teams left Cairo without a deal. Israel has repeatedly refused to agree to a permanent ceasefire in Gaza until Hamas has been defeated, even if all hostages are released. 

United Nations Resolution on Palestine:

  • The UN General Assembly (UNGA) passed a resolution calling on the UN Security Council to reconsider Palestinian membership to the UN. However, the US mission said the Palestinian Authority does not meet the criteria for UN membership and that the resolution does not resolve its previously raised concerns.
  • Israel’s Foreign Affairs Minister Israel Katz has condemned the resolution, calling it an “absurd decision.” Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and the Palestinian foreign ministry, meanwhile, applauded the vote. Abbas said the resolution is “consistent with international law.”

Hostage families expressed "immense frustration" over pause in talks during meeting with top US officials

National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan at the White House on April 24.

The families of the five Americans believed to held hostage in Gaza met with National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan and White House Middle East Coordinator Brett McGurk Friday, according to the White House.

Sullivan said bringing home the remaining hostages is the Biden administration’s priority and that CIA Director William Burns spent the week in the region working on that goal, readout said.

US says it is "reasonable to assess" Israel used American weapons in Gaza inconsistent with international law

A view of the destruction in Khan Yunis after Israeli attacks on April 8.

The Biden administration said Friday that it is “reasonable to assess” that US weapons have been used by Israeli forces in Gaza in ways that are inconsistent with international humanitarian law – but the highly anticipated report stopped short of officially saying Israel violated the law.

Investigations into potential violations are ongoing but the report noted that the United States does “not have complete information to verify” whether the US weapons “were specifically used” in alleged violations of international humanitarian law.

Here’s what the report said:

The report, which covers the period from the outbreak of the war with Hamas on October 7 to late April, did not find that Israel has withheld humanitarian aid to Gaza in violation of US law.

The high-stakes report was transmitted to Capitol Hill on Friday afternoon. The administration was required to make a determination on two matters under a February national security memorandum, which President Joe Biden issued under pressure from Democratic lawmakers. That memorandum requires all countries using US weapons to attest that they are doing so consistent with international humanitarian law and international human rights law.

Although the report does not find Israel in violation of either of the terms of the memorandum, it is sharply critical of the toll of Israel’s military campaign.

This post has been updated with additional information from the report.

Hamas says Israel sent hostage release talks back to "square one" after rejecting mediators' latest proposal

Visitors pay their respects at a memorial bearing portraits of people taken hostage or killed in the Hamas attack in southern Israel on May 9, 2024. 

Hamas militants on Friday said Israel’s rejection of a ceasefire plan submitted by mediators at negotiations in Cairo sent hostage release talks back to “square one.” 

In an English-language statement issued Friday, the Palestinian militant group said it had “responsibly” agreed to the plan brought by mediators in the hopes of achieving a “permanent ceasefire.” 

Hamas said it showed flexibility in agreeing to the deal, which would have involved the withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, the return of displaced civilians and the exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners as part of the permanent ceasefire. 

The militant group accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of hindering the ceasefire talks to use negotiations as a cover to attack the southern Gaza city of Rafah. Netanyahu “bears full responsibility for obstructing reaching an agreement,” the Hamas statement said.

The militant group’s statement comes a day after Israeli and Hamas negotiating teams left Cairo talks on the terms of a ceasefire and hostage release agreement, without a deal. Israel has repeatedly refused to agree to a permanent ceasefire in Gaza until Hamas has been defeated, even if all hostages are released. 

Biden faces bipartisan blowback over Israel ultimatum

President Joe Biden walks to board Marine One in the South Lawn of the White House on May 9, 2024.

US President Joe Biden is facing bipartisan blowback over his warning to Israel that a major Israeli offensive in the city of Rafah would result in a shut-off to some US weapons.

A group of 26 House Democrats sent a letter to Biden on Friday saying they are “deeply concerned about the message the Administration is sending to Hamas and other Iranian-backed terrorist proxies by withholding weapons shipments to Israel.” The letter does not specifically mention Biden’s interview with CNN this week where he first publicized his warning. 

The group of House Democrats, led by Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey, also requested a briefing from the White House to get more information on Biden’s decision, as well as how and when aid appropriated by Congress for Israel will be delivered.

Last week, Biden also signed off on a pause of 3,500 bombs to Israel that administration officials feared would be dropped on Rafah. 

Meanwhile, Republicans are seizing on Biden’s comments and his handling of foreign aid. GOP Rep. Cory Mills of Florida, a rank-and-file member, has indicated he plans to file a long-shot impeachment resolution against Biden, calling the ultimatum an impeachable offense and accusing the president of abusing his power, which comes as the House GOP’s other Biden impeachment efforts have sputtered.

House Oversight Chair James Comer, also a Republican, has opened a probe over Biden’s handling of aid to Israel in the wake of his latest comments saying he would halt some shipments of American weapons to Israel.

UN human rights chief denounces any actions that jeopardize entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza

United Nations Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk, at the United Nations in Geneva, Switzerland on February 29.

The human rights chief for the United Nations condemned all acts jeopardizing the entry and distribution of critically needed humanitarian aid into Gaza, according to a statement on Friday.

He urged “all parties to ensure that crossings for civilians and goods necessary for the survival of the civilian population are not placed at risk through military operations.”

Türk also called for an end to fighting to ensure sustained aid could enter Gaza.

"We are heading into the unknown": Food vendors in Rafah unsure where to go next 

A nearly deserted street in Rafah on May 10, 2024.

The streets of central and eastern Rafah are empty as civilians who previously sought refuge in the area are evacuating following calls to do so from the Israeli military.

One school which was turned into a shelter that once housed displaced Palestinians, is now empty and deserted. Tents that housed thousands of displaced people disappeared from the streets in the neighborhood. 

Another man with Abu Hesham, who did not provide his name, said they were able to sell to people leaving from the eastern part of Rafah, but that over the past few days, there has been little movement and they mainly sold supplies to Rafah residents.

“You can’t raise the prices. Now we can’t find goods to buy. We want to get enough money to get a car to move away from here,” he said.

The man said he would stay in Rafah.

Abu Hesham said he does not know where they will go, or how they will get enough money for even a ride into central Gaza, which is becoming more expensive. 

White House reaching out to Israel about CNN report on alleged systematic abuse at Israeli prison

A leaked photograph of the detention facility shows a blindfolded man with his arms above his head.

The White House said a CNN report on alleged systematic abuse at an Israeli prison was “deeply concerning” and that the Biden administration is reaching out to Israeli officials for answers.

He said the administration was seeking more information from Israeli officials. “Obviously, our expectation is that we’ll get good answers here,” he said. 

The United States expects its allies to provide “the highest standard when it comes to the treatment of prisoners,” Kirby said while adding he didn’t want to “get ahead of where we are.”

CNN has exclusive reporting on Israeli whistleblowers alleging systematic abuse in the Israeli prison of the Sde Teiman in the Negev desert.

White House says no indication of "large-scale invasion" of Rafah but administration is watching closely

Palestinians prepare to evacuate a tent camp after Israeli forces launched a ground and air operation in the eastern part of Rafah, on May 10, 2024

The White House said Friday it sees no indication of a “large-scale invasion” in Rafah – but the Biden administration is watching the situation closely and “with concern.” 

Kirby said that the forces in the area had been “put in there at the beginning.” 

“That said, we’re watching it with concern,” he said. “Every day that that crossing is not available and usable for humanitarian assistance, there’s going to be more suffering, and that’s of deep concern to us.” 

On a national security memorandum expected Friday detailing whether Israel violated the terms of a weapons agreement with the United States, Kirby said President Joe Biden had been briefed and was “obviously aware of the contents.” 

On Friday, the United Nations warned the situation in Gaza has reached “even more unprecedented levels of emergency,” with every single crossing into Rafah remaining closed.

South Africa asks International Criminal Court for urgent additional measures in Israel genocide case

In this January 2024 file photo, ICJ President Joan Donoghue and ICJ judges arrive at the International Court of Justice prior to the verdict announcement in the genocide case against Israel, brought by South Africa.

South Africa has filed an urgent request for additional measures in the International Court of Justice (ICJ) genocide case against Israel, a court statement from Friday shows.

CNN has reached out to the Israeli government for comment.

Some background: On March 28, the ICJ issued additional provisional measures against Israel in light of famine “settling in” Gaza. It followed the court’s original ruling in January ordering Israel to “take all measures” to prevent genocide after South Africa accused Israel of violating international laws on genocide in its war in the enclave.

The ICJ rejected Israel’s request for the case to be thrown out, saying there was a “plausible” case of genocide, but the court stopped short of ordering Israel to halt the war as South Africa had asked. 

Palestinian foreign ministry welcomes resolution on United Nations membership

The results of a vote on a resolution for the UN Security Council to reconsider and support the full membership of Palestine into the United Nations is displayed during a special session of the UN General Assembly, at UN headquarters in New York City on May 10, 2024.

The Palestinian Authority’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates has welcomed the passing of the UN General Assembly resolution that calls on the UN Security Council to reconsider Palestinian membership to the UN, according to a written statement published by the ministry on Friday.

The ministry also thanked the countries that sponsored and voted for the resolution and renewed its call to nations supporting the two-state solution and regional peace, to recognize a Palestinian state formally.

Some context: While a General Assembly vote cannot confer UN membership, the resolution does endow the Palestinian Authority with new procedural rights and privileges.

Only member states can vote, but the Palestinian Authority can now be seated among member states in alphabetical order; submit and introduce proposals and amendments; and co-sponsor proposals and amendments.

Israeli security cabinet approves expansion of Rafah operation, official says

Smoke rises above building at sunrise, in the aftermath of Israeli bombardment in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip on May 10, 2024

Israel’s security cabinet approved an “expansion of the area of operation” in Rafah late Thursday, an Israeli official said, one day after President Joe Biden threatened to withhold US weapons if Israel carries out an all-out offensive in the city.

The approval is a way for the cabinet to express its support for expanding military operations in Rafah and empowers the war cabinet to continue to make military decisions there without further consulting the security cabinet.

The approval is not an indication of an imminent expansion of Israeli military operations in Rafah.

Biden on Wednesday warned he would halt some shipments of American weapons to Israel — which he acknowledged have been used to kill civilians in Gaza — if Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu orders a “major invasion” of the city of Rafah.

Palestinian Authority president applauds UNGA’s vote for Palestinian statehood

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas attends the World Economic Forum in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on April 28.

Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas applauded the UN General Assembly’s overwhelming vote Friday in favor of the UN Security Council’s reconsideration of Palestine’s full UN membership.

He thanked countries that supported the resolution, which he said in a statement is “consistent with international law and expresses the international consensus in isolating the occupation and its crimes and serious violations of international legitimacy.”

Abbas added that, “in light of this vote, the State of Palestine will continue its endeavor to obtain full membership in the United Nations by a decision of the Security Council.” 

He called on the US to withdraw its veto and support the Palestinian Authority’s full UN membership.

Abbas highlighted the vote – which also granted the Palestinian Authority additional rights within the UN system but not full membership – as a restoration of faith in international legitimacy and law, crucial for regional peace.

Israel foreign minister condemns UNGA passing resolution calling for UN membership for Palestinian Authority 

Israel's Foreign Affairs Minister Israel Katz attends a meeting of the United Nations Security Council at U.N. headquarters in New York on March 11.

Israel’s Foreign Affairs Minister Israel Katz has condemned the passing of the UN General Assembly resolution on Friday calling for the UN Security Council to reconsider UN Membership for the Palestinian Authority.

Katz said the decision would further complicate negotiations surrounding the release of hostages held in Gaza, by providing “a tailwind to Hamas.”

The foreign minister thanked the countries that did not vote in favor of the resolution, who he says chose to “stand on the right side of history and morality.”

A United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) resolution calling on the UN Security Council to reconsider Palestinian membership to the UN passed on Friday, with 143 votes in favor, nine votes against and 25 abstaining. 

The resolution calls for the Security Council to “reconsider the matter favourably,” and stresses that the Palestinian Authority be granted UN membership, saying, “the State of Palestine is qualified for membership in the United Nations.”

Palestinian UN ambassador gives emotional address at UNGA session

Palestinian Ambassador to the United Nations Riyad Mansour gestures to delegates after addressing them during the UN General Assembly in New York, on May 10.

In a poignant address to the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) on Friday ahead of a crucial vote in the body, Palestinian Ambassador Riyad Mansour spoke passionately about the plight of his people, highlighting the dire situation in Gaza.

The UNGA session saw a vote on a draft resolution calling on the UN Security Council to reconsider the Palestinian Authority’s UN membership bid – which passed with 143 votes in favor.

Mentioning ongoing protests at Columbia University, Mansour paused briefly.

Mansour asserted Palestinian resilience, noting the symbolic significance of their flag flying proudly both in the Palestinian Territories and across the globe, including at Columbia University.

He underscored the urgent need for global solidarity in support of Gaza, stressing that while Palestinians will not disappear, the lives lost and the scars inflicted cannot be undone.

UNGA passes resolution calling on Security Council to reconsider Palestinian UN membership

Israeli Ambassador to the United Nations Gilad Erdan speaks during a special session at UN headquarters in New York, on May 10.

A United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) resolution calling on the UN Security Council to reconsider Palestinian membership to the UN passed on Friday, with 143 votes in favor, nine votes against and 25 abstaining. 

The resolution calls for the Security Council to “reconsider the matter favourably,” and stresses that the Palestinian Authority be granted UN membership, saying, “the State of Palestine is qualified for membership in the United Nations.”

Prior to the start of the UNGA session, the US Mission to the UN indicated that if the resolution was adopted and the membership application sent to the Security Council, the US would veto it again, saying, “We expect a similar outcome to what occurred in April.”

The US mission said the Palestinian Authority does not meet the criteria for UN membership and that the resolution does not resolve concerns previously raised about Palestinian membership.

In April, the Palestinian Authority relaunched its membership request, and later that month, the US vetoed the Palestinian attempt to achieve membership status. The vote in the Security Council saw 12 members in favor and one against, in addition to the US veto. Israel commended the US veto, calling the Palestinian bid a “shameful proposal” while the Palestinian Authority presidency called the veto “unfair, immoral and unjustified”.

In September 2011, the Palestinian Authority failed to win UN recognition as an independent member state. A year later, the UN decided that the Palestinian Authority’s “non-member observer entity” status would be changed to “non-member observer state,” similar to the Vatican.

"Destroyed from top to bottom": Gazans fleeing Rafah arrive in Khan Younis, an area already ravaged by war

Displaced Palestinians inspect their destroyed homes in Khan Younis, Gaza, after fleeing from Rafah on May 7.

People fleeing from the southern Gaza city of Rafah have described arriving in Khan Younis only to find it “completely destroyed,” with dire living conditions.

The UN’s agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) estimates nearly 110,000 people have fled Rafah since Monday, after the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) issued an evacuation order. Many of them arrived in Khan Younis, only to reach an area already devastated by war.

Amana added that her family had left Rafah under the bombardment, which was a “horror scene.”

Another man named Fayez Abu Amsha, originally a resident of Beit Hanoun in northern Gaza, told CNN that he and his family were told to flee to Rafah in the early days of the war.

Amsha and his family fled to Khan Younis to find an UNRWA school in the city “totally and completely destroyed and uninhabitable.”

Another elderly lady named Fatama Al-Masri, from Beit Hanoun, described dire living conditions in Khan Younis, including no water electricity or running water, and being left with no choice but to “defecate on the dirt.”

Rafah ground offensive would lead to an "epic humanitarian disaster," UN chief says

United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres attends a press conference at U.N. headquarters in New York City, on February 8.

UN chief Antonio Guterres warned on Friday that a massive ground attack in Rafah would lead to an “epic humanitarian disaster” as well as “pull the plug on our efforts to support people as famine looms.”

It comes as ceasefire-for-hostage talks are on “pause” while Israel steps up its military operation in Rafah, two US officials told CNN.

Guterres also stressed that the situation in Rafah “is on a knife’s edge,” as airstrikes continue throughout southern Gaza.

Guterres then reiterated his calls for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza, the immediate and unconditional release of hostages and the massive surge in life-saving aid.

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app on Google Play.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from Google Play.

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.