Biden says he is holding out hope for a Gaza ceasefire before Ramadan, despite stalled talks

March 9, 2024 Israel-Hamas war

By Chris Lau, Andrew Raine, Amarachi Orie, Tori B. Powell and Adrienne Vogt, CNN

Updated 0506 GMT (1306 HKT) March 10, 2024
32 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
6:55 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Biden says he is holding out hope for a Gaza ceasefire before Ramadan, despite stalled talks

From CNN’s Samantha Waldenberg

US President Joe Biden speaks at a campaign event in Philadelphia on March 8.
US President Joe Biden speaks at a campaign event in Philadelphia on March 8. Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images

US President Joe Biden said in an interview Saturday that a Gaza ceasefire deal before the start of Ramadan on Monday is still “possible,” mentioning that CIA Director Bill Burns is in the region to aid the negotiations “right at this minute.”

"I never give up on that," Biden told MSNBC’s Jonathan Capehart when asked if a ceasefire could be reached before the Muslim holy month begins.

CNN has previously reported that a ceasefire deal in Gaza — which would see Israeli hostages freed and the first break in fighting in more than three months — is unlikely to happen by the start of Ramadan, according to sources familiar with the negotiations.

On addressing Israeli lawmakers: Biden also said he would like to return to Israel and address the country’s parliament, the Knesset, but declined to discuss it in more detail when pressed by the MSNBC anchor.

Former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told CNN’s Fareed Zakaria last week that Biden should go over current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's head and address the parliament directly.

7:02 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Biden says there is no "red line" where he would cut off all weapons shipments to Israel

From CNN’s Donald Judd

US President Joe Biden pledged continued support for Israel but indicated there are "red lines" that Israel could cross in its war against Hamas in Gaza.

In an interview on MSNBC Saturday, Biden was asked if he has any "red line" with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Biden said the US wouldn’t cut off all weapons shipments to Israel.

"I'm never going to leave Israel. The defense of Israel is still critical. So there's no red line (where) I'm going to cut off all weapons so they don't have the Iron Dome to protect them," Biden said, referring to Israel's missile defense system.
"But there's red lines that if he crosses ... (we) cannot have 30,000 more Palestinians dead as a consequence of going after (Hamas)," Biden continued, but didn’t say exactly what those red lines entailed.

"There's other ways to deal ... with the trauma caused by Hamas," he added.

Biden has been increasingly vocal in his calls for Israel to more deliberately protect civilian life in Gaza over the last few weeks. 

“Israel has had the overwhelming support of the vast majority of nations,” Biden told comedian Seth Meyers in an interview last week. “If it keeps this up with this incredibly conservative government they have … they’re going to lose support from around the world.”

On Saturday, Biden told MSNBC he cautioned Israel’s war cabinet to not "make the mistake America made," referencing his visit to Israel in October of last year, where he cautioned Israelis not to be "consumed" by rage like America was after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

“America made a mistake. We went after (Osama) Bin Laden until we got him. But we shouldn't have gone into Ukraine,” Biden said, before correcting himself. “I mean, we shouldn't, we shouldn't have gone into the whole thing in Iraq and Afghanistan. It wasn't necessary, wasn't necessary.” 

5:41 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Airstrike hits residential buildings in central Gaza, killing 8, witnesses and hospital officials say

From CNN's Abeer Salman and Mohammed Tawfeeq

At least eight people were killed in an Israeli airstrike on buildings in central Gaza on Saturday afternoon local time, according to health officials at Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital and witnesses on the ground.

Several witnesses told CNN on Saturday that the airstrike hit residential buildings in Nuseirat in central Gaza.

A video obtained by CNN from the hospital shows at least four of the dead being brought from the area to the facility — including two children, who were found dead after being pulled out from under rubble.

CNN has reached out to the Israel Defense Forces for comment on the alleged airstrike. The IDF has repeatedly said they are "operating to dismantle Hamas military and administrative capabilities."

5:27 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Israeli police confront protesters demanding Netanyahu's ouster

From CNN’s Lauren Izso, Eyad Kourdi, Mohammed Tawfeeq and Jennifer Z. Deaton

Mounted Israeli security forces push protesters away from a road during a demonstration in Tel Aviv on March 9.
Mounted Israeli security forces push protesters away from a road during a demonstration in Tel Aviv on March 9. Jack Guez/AFP/Getty Images 

Thousands of protesters gathered again on Saturday in Israeli cities — including Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and the coastal town of Caesarea — to demand a general election and the removal of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu from government.

In Tel Aviv's Democracy Square, protesters chanted: "We will not stop until Bibi (Netanyahu) is arrested!"

"No to a government of terrorists!" one sign read.
"You are the leader; you are the guilty one!" other protesters chanted.

Police use water cannon to disperse protesters in Tel Aviv on March 9.
Police use water cannon to disperse protesters in Tel Aviv on March 9. Ariel Schalit/AP

As the night progressed, clashes erupted between Israeli police and some demonstrators. 

The Israeli police arrested 16 people, saying a group breached orders by "crossing fences," "throwing smoke grenade" toward an intersection and "firing a gas grenade" at both protesters and police.

Photos from the scene showed police on horseback and on foot attempting to disperse people, with some using water cannons on the protesters. 

5:13 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Gaza resident and NGO worker says getting aid trucks into strip would be more efficient than airdrops and port

Yousef Hammash speaks with CNN.
Yousef Hammash speaks with CNN. CNN via Skype

Yousef Hammash, a Gaza resident and advocacy officer for the Norwegian Refugee Council, said the efforts on airdrops and plans for a port in Gaza would be better put toward getting aid trucks directly into the strip.

"First thing: Any small help, even for one child, (is) worth it. But I don't think that it was realistic to spend all that amount of effort on airdropping," he told CNN in an interview from the southernmost city of Rafah.

Palestinian children wait to receive food cooked by a charity kitchen amid shortages of food supplies, in Rafah, Gaza, on March 5.
Palestinian children wait to receive food cooked by a charity kitchen amid shortages of food supplies, in Rafah, Gaza, on March 5. Mohammed Salem/Reuters

He said the US plan to build a temporary port off the coast — which the Pentagon says could take up to two months to complete — is also "kind of unrealistic, to be honest."

His comments echo those made by United Nations and aid agency officials.

Hammash said the international community — especially the US — should instead focus on using its influence to get aid trucks into Gaza as hunger threatens the enclave. Israel has maintained severe restrictions on that access, allowing aid via ground routes only in a trickle.

"We are lacking literally everything: We are lacking electricity, fuel, food, water — anything (for) our basic needs," especially in northern Gaza, he said.

Hammash called for a permanent ceasefire to the war. "We don't want to find ourselves in that circle of violence again and again," he said.

5:05 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Trudeau discusses hostage efforts and looming Rafah offensive in call with Israeli war cabinet member

From CNN's Paula Newton, Lauren Izso and Eyad Kourdi

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau waits to greet Ecuador's President Daniel Noboa in Ottawa, Canada, on March 5.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau waits to greet Ecuador's President Daniel Noboa in Ottawa, Canada, on March 5. Blair Gable/Reuters

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau held a phone call with Benny Gantz — a key figure in the Israeli war cabinet — on Friday to discuss Israel, the West Bank and Gaza.

The two leaders called for the immediate release of all remaining hostages held in Gaza and urged the international community to keep working toward their release, the Canadian prime minister's office said in a statement Saturday.

Trudeau, however, expressed his concern about "Israel's planned offensive in the southern Gaza city of Rafah and the severe humanitarian implications for all civilians taking refuge in the area," according to the statement.

"The protection of civilians is paramount and a requirement under international humanitarian law," Trudeau added in the statement. 

Remember: Gantz has previously said Israel will expand military operations in Rafah — where displaced Palestinians are now sheltering by the thousands in desperate conditions — if a deal is not reached by the start of Ramadan early next week. That has caused panic in the southern city. Gazans say they have nowhere left to flee, and the United Nations aid chief has warned of a potential "slaughter" if Israeli troops move in.

3:18 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

The US conducted more airdrops in Gaza, but aid groups question the effectiveness. Here's what you should know

From CNN staff

The US conducted another humanitarian assistance airdrop into northern Gaza on Saturday, according to US Central Command. The airdrop included supplies equal to more than 41,400 meals and 23,000 bottles of water, CENTCOM said in a statement.

But the United Nations and aid agencies have questioned the effectiveness of ongoing airdrops from several countries. The risks were shown starkly on Friday when malfunctioning parachutes caused aid pallets to hurtle from the sky at breakneck speed, killing five unsuspecting people.

While Israel continues to severely restrict the distribution of aid within the enclave, some critics have said the American effort should instead be focused on halting Israel's military campaign and pressuring the US ally to allow critical humanitarian access.

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • Humanitarian crisis: Water, hygiene and sanitation services “remain severely constrained” in the war-torn strip, the United Nations said. At least two more people died in Gaza on Saturday due to severe malnutrition and dehydration, bringing the total number of people to 25, according to a spokesperson for the Palestinian Ministry of Health in Gaza. Four out of every five households in Gaza are without safe water, the UN warned Saturday. 
  • Embattled UN agency: Canada and Sweden will both resume funding to the main United Nations aid agency in Gaza, the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East, after previously pulling support over Israel's claim that staff members were involved in the October 7 attacks. Both governments cited stricter controls within the organization, and its critical role in aid distribution. The head of the agency has said repeatedly that Israel has not provided evidence to support its allegations, while a UN investigation continues.
  • Rafah residential strike: A strike on a residential building left scores of civilian wounded in the southernmost Gaza city of Rafah on Saturday, according to the Palestinian news agency WAFA. The Israel Defense Forces said it targeted a Hamas military asset in the area.
  • Houthi attacks: The United States and coalition forces downed at least 28 unmanned aircraft flown by the Houthi rebel group during a "large-scale" attack in the Red Sea area Saturday, according to US Central Command. The wave of drones comes in spite of continued US and coalition airstrikes against Houthi targets in Yemen, and on the heels of other attacks over the past several days. The Houthis say their campaign is aimed at pressuring Israel to end its war in Gaza.
  • Another heated exchange: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu rebuked Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Saturday for calling his government "mass murderers" and once again comparing Israel's administration to Nazis for its actions in Gaza. Relations between Turkey and Israel have sunken to a new low during the war, with the two leaders repeatedly verbally sparring. Netanyahu condemned Erdogan's support of Hamas and called the Turkish president a hypocrite on human rights issues.
2:53 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

US says it shot down at least 28 Houthi drones after "large-scale" attack over the Red Sea

From CNN’s Lauren Koenig

The United States and coalition forces downed at least 28 unmanned aircraft flown by the Houthi rebel group in the Red Sea area Saturday, according to US Central Command. 

In a statement, CENTCOM wrote the "defeat" of the Houthi attack came "following further engagements through the morning." No US vessels or commercial ships were damaged in the attack, according to the statement.

CNN reported earlier that US forces shot down over a dozen drones launched by the Iranian-backed Houthis over the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden Saturday morning local time, according to CENTCOM, after the Houthis conducted a “large-scale” drone attack.

For context: The wave of drones comes in spite of continued US and coalition airstrikes against Houthi targets in Yemen.

The first fatal attack by the Iran-backed militant group occurred this week, when at least three crew members were killed and four others injured in the assault Wednesday on the M/V True Confidence, a Barbados-flagged, Liberian-owned bulk carrier.

The Houthis have been targeting shipping in the Red Sea since shortly after the war between Israel and Hamas began, with the group tying the attacks to its effort to pressure Israel and its allies to stop the war in Gaza. They are among several Iranian proxy groups at the center of global concerns the war could spill further through the Mideast.

2:11 p.m. ET, March 9, 2024

Why aid experts say the risks of airdrops outweigh their benefits

From CNN's Niamh Kennedy

US service members secure humanitarian aid, bound for airdrop over Gaza, onto a cargo aircraft on March 1. 
US service members secure humanitarian aid, bound for airdrop over Gaza, onto a cargo aircraft on March 1.  Tech. Sgt. Christopher Hubenthal/US Air Force/Handout/Reuters

The US has joined several other countries in airdropping aid into Gaza, which is grappling with a humanitarian crisis.

Aid deliveries on land are severely restricted by Israel and falling far short of the numbers needed to ward off famine in the enclave, so it is hoped these airdrops will provide a lifeline to civilians.

But the United Nations and aid agencies have questioned how effective they will be at alleviating the situation, and their risks were shown starkly on Friday when malfunctioning parachutes caused aid pallets to hurtle from the sky at breakneck speed, killing five unsuspecting people.

Photo ops and pitfalls: Airdrops evade the often rigorous examinations carried out at land checkpoints, so are undoubtedly a speedy way of getting supplies into a conflict zone. But despite this advantage, aid agencies say their drawbacks overwhelmingly outweigh their benefits.

For starters, they are more expensive. Airdrops cost up to seven times as much as land deliveries, the World Food Programme says. They also have much more limited delivery capacity. For example, one truck is capable of delivering nearly 10 times the amount one aircraft could deliver — roughly 20 to 30 metric tonnes, according to the UN.

“Humanitarian workers always complain that airdrops are good photo opportunities but a lousy way to deliver aid,” according to Richard Gowan, the International Crisis Group’s UN director.

Experts have also questioned whether countries have plans in place for the aid once it reaches the ground. The UN special rapporteur on the right to food, Michael Fakhri, says airdrops usually culminate in chaos.

Read more about the history of airdrops and why they are being carried out now in Gaza.