House Freedom Caucus member does not rule out backing Rep. Emmer for speaker

October 24, 2023 - Rep. Mike Johnson selected as next speaker nominee

By Mike Hayes, Shania Shelton and Jack Forrest, CNN

Updated 9:09 a.m. ET, October 25, 2023
27 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
12:17 p.m. ET, October 24, 2023

House Freedom Caucus member does not rule out backing Rep. Emmer for speaker

From CNN's Liz Brown-Kaiser

Rep. Ralph Norman speaks to members of the media prior to a House Republican caucus meeting in the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on October 12.
Rep. Ralph Norman speaks to members of the media prior to a House Republican caucus meeting in the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on October 12. Al Drago/Bloomberg/Getty Images

South Carolina Republican Rep. Ralph Norman told CNN's Kasie Hunt that he voted for fellow Freedom Caucus member Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida for speaker three times this morning but did not rule out supporting GOP Whip Tom Emmer of Minnesota in the future. 

"Trust is something people are looking for," Norman said, adding that "Tom's honest."

"All these votes go into the equation, but Tom is an honest man," the South Carolina Republican said when pressed about Emmer's vote to certify the 2020 election. "I don't agree with that vote."

Norman noted that Republicans need someone "we can trust" and said "we'll find out who that person is and are they gonna do what they say." He stressed that he wants commitments from all speaker candidates on what they will and won't do while holding the gavel. Specifically, Norman said the Freedom Caucus wants to sit down with the nominee and ask tough questions.

"No," Norman responded when asked by Hunt if he feels pressure to select a speaker today. He argued the position is too important to rush and that the American people are more concerned about issues like gas prices and the border, while the speaker's battle isn't their "highest concern."

The congressman also said that Ukraine and Israel aid must be weighed by Congress in two separate votes, rather than being linked. 

11:55 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Hern and Donalds both out as House GOP begins 5th round of voting

From CNN's Haley Talbot

Reps. Kevin Hern of Oklahoma and Byron Donalds of Florida are both out as House Republicans begin their fifth round of voting.

There are just two candidates left: Reps. Tom Emmer of Minnesota and Mike Johnson of Louisiana.

11:41 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Speaker candidates want 217 votes before going to the floor, but not everyone in House GOP is convinced

From CNN's Annie Grayer, Lauren Fox and Manu Raju

Members of the House of Representatives vote on the House Speaker on October 20 in Washington, DC.
Members of the House of Representatives vote on the House Speaker on October 20 in Washington, DC. Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

During the speaker candidate forum on Monday, all the speaker candidates agreed that they wanted to get to 217 votes in the room before going to the floor, a source familiar told CNN. But that doesn’t mean it will officially happen. 

As the voting gets down to the wire, House Republicans will have to decide yet again whether they should stay behind closed doors until a speaker nominee locks in 217 votes, or again go to the House floor with a nominee who has just won a majority of the conference and risk more public embarrassment. 

Speaker candidate GOP Rep. Kevin Hern told CNN on Monday that he and other candidates in the race believe the conference should hold a private roll call vote ahead of going to the House floor to test whether the GOP nominee has 217 votes to be elected. That would avoid the spectacle on the floor that derailed Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan’s bid. 

“I think the consensus is, and I've talked to some of the other people that are running and others that are actually going to be the voting members, and we'd like to see a roll call vote in the basement so that we know this. Because the American people don't want to see another thing that happened like last week with Jim Jordan,” he said. 

GOP Rep. Tim Burchett of Tennessee told CNN it is important for the conference to 217 behind closed doors because they need to avoid another public embarrassment on the House floor. 

“I do not think it will go to the floor until we have 217 committed,” Burchett said. “If it goes to the floor, it will succeed.”

But not all Republicans are sold on the strategy. Texas GOP Rep. Dan Crenshaw told CNN, “it’s impossible” for the conference to get to 217, but added “let’s see who wins. The rebels might be tired.”

GOP Rep. Ralph Norman of South Carolina told reporters in between voting rounds that the conference decided to have a roll call vote once the race narrows to the final two candidates so members can be on the record with who they support.

“We’ll pare it down And then we get it down to I assume the two, we will have a roll call vote.”

11:40 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Scott is out after third round of secret ballot voting

From CNN's Haley Talbot

Rep. Austin Scott in the Longworth Building on Friday, October 13.
Rep. Austin Scott in the Longworth Building on Friday, October 13. Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call/Getty Images

Georgia Rep. Austin Scott is out as the House GOP heads into their fourth round of voting.

There are four remaining candidates – Reps. Tom Emmer of Minnesota, Mike Johnson of Louisiana, Kevin Hern of Oklahoma and Byron Donalds of Florida.

Emmer again received the most votes in the third round of voting.

Here's the latest vote tally, according to two sources:

  • Emmer - 100
  • Johnson - 43
  • Donalds - 32
  • Hern - 26
  • Scott- 12
  • Other- 3
  • Present- 3

Remember: Members are casting a successive series of secret ballots, with the candidate who garners the fewest number of votes in each round dropped from the running.

The process will continue until there are only two candidates left or, until one candidate receives a majority of the conferences’ votes — whichever comes first.

Here, a plurality of votes is not enough. The winning candidate will need 50% +1 of the conference or a minimum of 113 votes. The conference vote is expected to take several hours as there will be several rounds of votes. 

11:44 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Emmer is the top vote getter in second round of voting

From CNN's Haley Talbot

House Majority Whip Tom Emmer is seen outside a House Republican Conference speaker election meeting in Longworth Building on Tuesday, October 24. 
House Majority Whip Tom Emmer is seen outside a House Republican Conference speaker election meeting in Longworth Building on Tuesday, October 24.  Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Getty Images

GOP Whip Rep. Tom Emmer, who is considered the frontrunner and is endorsed by Kevin McCarthy, received the most votes in two rounds of secret ballot voting for a House speaker nominee, according to members.

This was the vote tally in the second round, according to two sources:

  • Emmer - 90
  • Rep. Mike Johnson of Louisiana - 37
  • Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida - 33
  • Rep. Kevin Hern of Oklahoma - 31 
  • Rep. Austin Scott of Georgia - 14
  • Rep. Jack Bergman of Michigan - 7
  • Other- 3
  • Present- 2

Bergman was dropped from the speaker race after the second round as he received the least votes.

11:25 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

The House GOP is voting for a speaker nominee by secret ballot. Here's how the process works

From CNN's Haley Talbot

The US Capitol is seen on Monday.
The US Capitol is seen on Monday. Drew Angerer/Getty Images

House Republicans are meeting now to pick a new speaker.

With multiple candidates currently in the running, members are casting a successive series of secret ballots, with the candidate who garners the fewest number of votes in each round dropped from the running.

The process will continue until there are only two candidates left or, until one candidate receives a majority of the conferences’ votes — whichever comes first.

Here, a plurality of votes is not enough. The winning candidate will need 50% +1 of the conference or a minimum of 113 votes. The conference vote is expected to take several hours as there will be several rounds of votes. 

The following candidates are now seeking to be next House speaker:

  • Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida, a second-term member of the far-right Freedom Caucus.
  • GOP Whip Tom Emmer, a Minnesota Republican who is endorsed by Kevin McCarthy. 
  • Rep. Kevin Hern of Oklahoma, chair of the conservative group known as the Republican Study Committee – which wields a large bloc of GOP members.
  • Rep. Mike Johnson of Louisiana, the vice chairman for the House Republican Conference.

The speaker-designee will determine the next floor vote.

11:03 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Bergman out of the speaker's race after second secret ballot vote

From CNN's Haley Talbot

Rep. Jack Bergman
Rep. Jack Bergman Michael Brochstein/Zuma/AP

Rep. Jack Bergman of Michigan is out of the speaker's race after the second secret ballot vote of the GOP conference.

We are now entering ballot number three with the following members still as candidates:

  • Rep. Byron Donalds of Florida 
  • Rep. Tom Emmer of Minnesota
  • Rep. Kevin Hern of Oklahoma
  • Rep. Mike Johnson of Louisiana 
  • Rep. Austin Scott of Georgia

10:53 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Rep. Allen says he won't vote for Emmer on the floor

From CNN's Clare Foran and Manu Raju

Rep. Rick Allen leaves the House Republicans' caucus meeting at the Capitol Hill Club in Washington DC, on Tuesday, May 23.
Rep. Rick Allen leaves the House Republicans' caucus meeting at the Capitol Hill Club in Washington DC, on Tuesday, May 23. Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call/Getty Images

Republican Rep. Rick Allen told CNN's Manu Raju he would not vote for Rep. Tom Emmer on the House floor, saying he’s “very concerned” about Emmer’s vote to codify same-sex marriage in the last Congress.  

“No,” he said when asked if there was any way he would vote for him.

This comes as other members, particularly those of the hardline Freedom Caucus, have expressed reservations about supporting Emmer on the floor if he wins the GOP nomination. 

10:54 a.m. ET, October 24, 2023

Trump’s posture on Emmer’s speaker bid shifted after his tweet

From CNN's Kristen Holmes

Former President Donald Trump delivers remarks during a campaign event on October 23, in Derry, New Hampshire.
Former President Donald Trump delivers remarks during a campaign event on October 23, in Derry, New Hampshire. Scott Eisen/Getty Images

Former President Donald Trump’s posture on Rep. Tom Emmer has shifted in the last 12 hours, according to two sources close to Trump. 

While there is a lot of fraught history between many Trump allies and Emmer, Trump had privately and publicly indicated that he would stay neutral in the speaker’s race. Monday morning, multiple sources in touch with Trump described him as "uninvolved" and "unfocused" on the happenings in the House. 

That changed Monday afternoon when Trump was shown a tweet from Emmer responding to Trump’s remarks in New Hampshire. 

Trump was angered by the familiarity of the tweet and according to one source, the “deception” that Emmer and Trump had a relationship that they do not. 

“Thank you, Mr. President,” Emmer tweeted on a video of Trump saying he and Emmer got along. “If my colleagues elect me Speaker of the House, I look forward to continuing our strong working relationship.”

“Tom Emmer has not been a friend to Donald Trump for 4-5 years,” a source close to Trump said. “Now he’s painting himself as the Trump candidate or Trump whisperer and it’s just not true.”