Families of American hostages held by Hamas describe meeting with Harris as productive

April 9, 2024 - Israel-Hamas war

By Chris Lau, Antoinette Radford, Leinz Vales, Tori B. Powell and Aditi Sangal, CNN

Updated 12:02 a.m. ET, April 10, 2024
39 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
5:18 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Families of American hostages held by Hamas describe meeting with Harris as productive

From CNN's Sam Fossum

The families of American hostages who are being held by Hamas in Gaza said they had a productive meeting Tuesday with Vice President Kamala Harris.

“One of the things we talked about is that there is a possibility to holding two truths: You can believe, as we do, that it is horrible innocent civilians in Gaza are suffering and at the same time you can also know that it is horrible and against international law for hostages to be held against their will," parent Rachel Goldberg-Polin told reporters at the White House Tuesday. 

Goldberg-Polin, whose son Hersh is one of the eight Americans held in captivity, said that the families are thinking about all the hostages as she said they are demanding results – not progress.  

“We want results," she said. "And we are so grateful and thankful to the American administration and Congress to all of the support, but we need results. We need our people home.”

Jonathan Dekel-Chen, father of hostage Sagui Dekel-Chen, said they are encouraging all parties involved to reach a deal as negotiations continue in Egypt.

“We all are here, for not the first time, to work together with the Biden Administration to do everything that we can and encourage all parties to reach a deal that will result in our loved ones coming home,” he said. 

The vice president’s office said Harris “expressed her continued support for these families” as she provided an update on US efforts. 

5:20 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Health workers exhume nearly 400 bodies from Al-Shifa Hospital after IDF withdrawal. Here's the latest

From CNN staff

A boy stands by the rubble of a collapsed building in Rafah, Gaza, on April 9.
A boy stands by the rubble of a collapsed building in Rafah, Gaza, on April 9. AFP/Getty Images

Health workers in northern Gaza exhumed at least 381 bodies from mass graves in and around Al-Shifa Hospital Tuesday, after they said Israeli forces killed hundreds of Palestinians and left their bodies to decompose during their two-week siege of the complex.

The number of those exhumed today does not include people buried within the grounds of the hospital, according to Gaza Civil Defense spokesperson Mahmoud Basal.

Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the director-general of the World Health Organization, said several United Nations agencies are assisting in efforts to retrieve bodies to provide "dignified burials."

Here are other headlines you should know:

  • Proposed deal: In a statement published early Tuesday, Hamas said the latest deal proposed by Israel does not meet their demands. The group said its leaders would review the proposal and inform mediators of their response. US President Joe Biden’s top national security aide said he asked interlocutors for Hamas to press for a quick response to the proposal.
  • Report on Israeli war crimes: Children in Gaza have been dying from “starvation-related complications” since Israel began using starvation as a weapon of war — which is a war crime — Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in a report Tuesday. Israel denies the accusation, despite widespread evidence of malnutrition in Gaza.
  • Germany's response to Nicaragua: Germany has hit back at accusations from Nicaragua at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that it has been “facilitating genocide” in Gaza through its support for Israel, insisting that Israeli security is at the "core" of German foreign policy.
  • US weapons and response to genocide claims: US Rep. Gregory Meeks — the top Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee — says he is not yet ready to sign off on the sale of dozens of American-made F-15 fighter jets and related munitions to Israel as he seeks “assurances” on how the weapons would be used. Also, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin told lawmakers Tuesday that to his knowledge, the US does not have evidence of Israel committing genocide in its war in Gaza.

  • Humanitarian aid: Turkey announced new restrictions on exports to Israel on Tuesday after Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan accused Israel of denying a request to airdrop aid to Gaza. Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz responded, saying that Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is "once again sacrificing the economic interests of the people of Turkey for his support of Hamas," adding that Israel will "respond accordingly." Elsewhere, French Foreign Minister Stephane Sejourne suggested that imposing EU sanctions could be a way to pressure Israel into opening Gaza border crossings for humanitarian aid. Also, Austin said the US military’s pier in Gaza, for delivering aid by sea, would "probably" be ready by April 21. Meanwhile, Tuesday saw the highest number of aid trucks to enter Gaza since October 7, according to Israel’s agency that controls access to Gaza.
  • Developments on the ground: The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) killed the mayor of the Al-Maghazi refugee camp in a strike in central Gaza on Monday, the IDF and Hamas both said. Hamas called it “a cowardly assassination." Also, the IDF said for the first time, the maritime air defense system known as "C-Dome" has intercepted a drone. And, cross-border attacks between Israel and Hezbollah have forced tens of thousands of people from their homes along both sides of the Lebanon-Israel border.
  • Rafah updates: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday that “no force in the world” will stop Israeli troops from entering Rafah in southern Gaza to eliminate Hamas units said to be there. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Israel still has not told the US the date of their announced invasion of Rafah, but that he expects the Biden administration will see “Israeli colleagues again next week” for discussions on the issue. And, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant did not indicate to Austin on a phone call Monday that a date has been set for Israel's incursion into Rafah, multiple people familiar with the call told CNN.
  • Hostage latest: Vice President Kamala Harris met with US families whose loved ones were taken hostage by Hamas where the families were updated on American efforts to secure the release of all hostages and a ceasefire. The families of American-Israeli hostages in Gaza also met with US National Security adviser Jake Sullivan Monday in Washington to press for their immediate release, according to the Hostages Families Forum Headquarters.
9:14 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Egyptian leader reaffirms commitment to resolve Gaza conflict in call with Palestinian Authority leader

From CNN's Mia Alberti

Egyptian leaders have reaffirmed to the Palestinian Authority their commitment and efforts to resolving the conflict in Gaza.

"Egypt is making every effort and making contacts with all international and regional parties in order to stop the aggression against the Palestinian people, provide humanitarian aid and prevent displacement," Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi told Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian news agency WAFA reports. 

In a joint phone conversation on Tuesday, the two leaders discussed the need to speed up the introduction of a ceasefire and more humanitarian and medical aid. The leaders also talked about how to prevent further military escalation and displacement of civilians in Gaza and the West Bank.

Abbas thanked his Egyptian counterpart for his support in "mobilizing international consensus" toward an end to hostilities and the recognition of the Palestinian state. 

The call comes amid ongoing negotiations in Cairo between Israel and Hamas. The United States, Egypt and Qatar are mediating the talks aimed at accomplishing a prisoner exchange deal and a pause in fighting. 

5:18 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Biden administration believes Netanyahu's claim of invasion date for Rafah is a bluster, senior officials say

From CNN's MJ Lee and Alex Marquardt

 The Biden administration is dismissing Benjamin Netanyahu’s pronouncement that a date has been set for a ground offensive into Rafah as bluster that is in no small part fueled by the Israeli prime minister’s tenuous political standing at home, senior administration officials told CNN.

The prime minister has been struggling to balance his stated goal of eliminating Hamas with the tremendous pressure of reaching a ceasefire that would see Israeli hostages freed. Israeli officials argue that four Hamas battalions remain in Rafah that must be taken out.

The administration's private view: Privately, multiple senior administration officials chalked up Netanyahu’s pronouncement to bravado.

The administration's public statements: Top officials have been publicly questioning Netanyahu’s insistence that Israel has decided on a time to mount an offensive into the southern Gaza city. American officials have reiterated that the US has not seen anything resembling a comprehensive plan from the Israelis on how they would carry out such an operation, including first moving the majority of the estimated 1.4 million civilians out of Rafah. 

Here's what top US officials have been saying:

  • Secretary of State: “We do not have a date for any Rafah operation, at least one that’s been communicated to us by the Israelis,” Antony Blinken said Tuesday. “I don’t see anything imminent."
  • National Security Adviser: “If he has a date he hasn’t share it with us,” Jake Sullivan told reporters Tuesday. 
  • US Defense Secretary: Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant told Lloyd Austin that Israel is still putting together a plan and making necessary preparations for a potential invasion of Rafah, and did not indicate that a date has been set for the operation, multiple people familiar with the call told CNN.      
10:16 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Tuesday saw the highest number of aid trucks to enter Gaza since October 7, Israel says

From CNN’s Benjamin Brown in London

Tuesday saw the highest number of aid trucks to enter Gaza since October 7, according to Israel’s agency that controls access to Gaza.

After inspection, 468 trucks carrying humanitarian aid were transferred to Gaza on Tuesday, Israel’s Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) said.

Additionally, 303 packages carrying "thousands" of meals were airdropped over Gaza on Tuesday, Israel’s military said. Humanitarian organizations have warned that airdrops are "good photo opportunities but a lousy way to deliver aid."

While there had been “an uptick” in the number of trucks entering in recent days, not all trucks were able to cross into Gaza at full capacity for security reasons, UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric said Tuesday, adding that different metrics of delivering aid have to be assessed beyond counting the number of trucks.

Before the conflict, an average of 450 to 500 trucks would enter Gaza daily with supplies, according to UN figures. The previous highest number had been reached on Monday, with 419 trucks entering the Strip.

3:56 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

"Israel has not done enough" to avert famine in Gaza, top US official for humanitarian aid tells Senate

From CNN's Michael Conte

Israel has not done enough to get food into Gaza amid “famine-like conditions,” USAID Administrator Samantha Power said Tuesday.

“I think Israel has not done enough to facilitate the kind of access we need to revert the kind of food conditions that we’re seeing to avert famine,” Power said at a Senate Appropriations State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs Subcommittee hearing.

Power said that there has been “a sea change” over the past few days in the amount of aid Israel is allowing into Gaza after “a series of restrictions over many, many months” from Israel.

“We have famine-like conditions in Gaza, and supermarkets filled with food within a few kilometers away. So it’s incredibly important that the food that is available get to the people,” Power said. “Especially in the case of very young children, we’re getting a growing number of reports of death by malnutrition or diseases induced by malnutrition.”

3:56 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

Israeli defense minister did not indicate date set for Rafah offensive in call with Austin, sources say

From CNN's Natasha Bertrand and Oren Liebermann

Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant did not indicate to US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin on a phone call Monday that a date has been set for Israel's incursion into Rafah, multiple people familiar with the call told CNN.

He told Austin that Israel is still putting together a plan for a potential assault on the southern Gaza city and making necessary preparations, including when it comes to the protection of civilians, the sources said.

Gallant suggested that the timeline is still being worked on, in contrast to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who said on Monday “there is a date” set for a move on Rafah.

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken also said on Tuesday that Israel has not told the US any date for a Rafah incursion, but that he expected the Biden administration to see “Israeli colleagues again next week” for discussions on the issue.

3:06 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

US is pressing Qatar for quick answer from Hamas on hostage proposal, national security adviser says

From CNN's Kevin Liptak

US President Joe Biden’s top national security aide said he asked interlocutors for Hamas to press for a quick response to a proposal for Gaza ceasefire and hostage release.

National Security adviser Jake Sullivan said he made the request in a phone call Tuesday morning with Qatar’s prime minister, who has acted as a mediator in the ongoing talks to free hostages in exchange for a pause in fighting.

“He does not yet have an answer from Hamas,” Sullivan said. “I pressed him to try to secure an answer from them as soon as possible.”

Meanwhile, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has not shared his plans for an invasion of Rafah with the United States after saying Monday a date had been set for the operation. “If he has a date, he hasn’t shared it with us,” Sullivan said, repeating US concerns at over a massive ground invasion of the southern Gaza city. 

“There are better ways to go after Hamas,” he said, adding that the White House had presented those options to Israeli officials last week.

1:21 p.m. ET, April 9, 2024

"The smell of the dead is all over the place": First bodies exhumed from mass graves at Al-Shifa Hospital

From CNN's Kareem Khadder and Sana Noor Haq

A United Nations team looks on as Gaza Civil Defense recover human remains the grounds of Al-Shifa hospital, in Gaza, on April 8, 2024.
A United Nations team looks on as Gaza Civil Defense recover human remains the grounds of Al-Shifa hospital, in Gaza, on April 8, 2024. AFP/Getty Images

Health workers in northern Gaza exhumed the first corpses from mass graves in and around Al-Shifa Hospital on Tuesday, after they said Israeli forces killed hundreds of Palestinians and left their bodies to decompose during their two-week siege of the complex.

At least 381 bodies were recovered from the vicinity of the complex since Israeli forces withdrew on April 1, Gaza Civil Defense spokesperson Mahmoud Basal said on Tuesday, adding that the total figure did not include people buried within the grounds of the hospital.

Many of the decomposed remnants they discovered had been buried or were found above ground, officials told CNN on Monday. Israeli tanks crushed others to death, leaving some of those killed completely disfigured and unable to be identified, Basal said.

Witnesses and civilians who were trapped inside the hospital when it was raided say the vicinity “was full of bodies,” according to Basal. “The occupation forces have plowed these bodies and buried them in the ground,” he added. 

CNN has reached out to the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) for comment.

“The smell of the dead is all over the place,” Motasem Salah, an official from the Ministry of Health in Gaza leading recovery efforts, told CNN. “We try to identify the bodies of these civilians as their families are awaiting news about their loved ones – if they are alive or missing.”

Khadr Al-Za’anoun of Wafa, the official Palestinian news agency, contributed to this report.