Catch up on what has happened in court so far — and what is coming next

Day 1 of Trump New York hush money trial

By Kara Scannell, Jeremy Herb, Maureen Chowdhury, Kaanita Iyer, Aditi Sangal and Elise Hammond, CNN

Updated 9:30 a.m. ET, April 22, 2024
67 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
1:19 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Catch up on what has happened in court so far — and what is coming next

From CNN staff

In this court sketch, former US President Donald Trump enters the courtroom with his attorney Todd Blanche at the beginning of Monday's trial at Manhattan Criminal Court in New York.
In this court sketch, former US President Donald Trump enters the courtroom with his attorney Todd Blanche at the beginning of Monday's trial at Manhattan Criminal Court in New York. Jane Rosenberg/Pool/Reuters

The historic criminal trial against former President Donald Trump is underway in New York. Ahead of jury selection, the judge said what evidence will be allowed — and what will not — during the trial.

Trump, who is in the courtroom, is on trial in Manhattan for his alleged role in a hush money scheme to silence his alleged mistresses before the 2016 election. No former US president has ever faced criminal prosecution. Trump has pleaded not guilty and has denied the affairs.

Here’s what has happened in court so far: 

 Evidence that will be allowed: 

  • Judge Juan Merchan said he will allow a series of National Enquirer stories attacking Trump's opponents into evidence.  
  • Testimony from Karen McDougal will also be allowed, but Merchan said it is not necessary for the jury to hear that Trump continued his affair with McDougal while his wife, Melania Trump, was pregnant and after she gave birth. McDougal is a model and actress who has said she had a monthslong affair with Trump in 2006 and was paid $150,000 to keep quiet about it by the National Enquirer. Trump has denied the affair. 
  • Merchan will allow testimony of former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen's guilty plea to campaign finance violations with the proper foundation. He said prosecutors cannot tie that guilty plea to Trump

What will not be allowed: 

  • Merchan said he still believes the "Access Hollywood" video in which Trump brags about groping women should not be shown to jurors because it's so prejudicial.  
  • The judge also denied prosecutors' request to bring into evidence the allegations of sexual assault against Trump that came out after the "Access Hollywood" tape. He said he will not allow Trump to be prejudiced by a "rumor." 
  • Merchan additionally said he doesn’t think the deposition of E. Jean Carroll, who accused Trump of sexual assault, should be brought in because it would be "building in a trial into a trial." 

What comes next: Jury selection is expected to begin soon and will continue until a panel of 12 New Yorkers and six alternates are seated. Prospective jurors will be vetted through a questionnaire that could signal political views. They will be asked a wide range of questions, including where in the city they live, where they get their news, whether they’ve ever attended a rally for the former president and whether they have had any affiliation with groups such as the Proud Boys or the QAnon movement. Read more about the process here.

1:11 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Prosecutors turned Trump's words into "weapons against him," CNN analyst says

One of the biggest takeaways from today's legal proceedings so far is that former President Donald Trump "had to sit and listen to prosecutors essentially turn his own words into weapons against him," New York Times reporter and CNN political analyst Maggie Haberman said.

Haberman, who was in the courtroom, pointed to prosecutors bringing up Trump's social media posts against Michael Cohen from his time in the White House and the Access Hollywood tape.

Such evidence "really underscores that this trial is going to be filled with personal discomfort for Donald Trump, who has often been able to just attack and then walk away," Haberman said. "This is going to be much harder for him here."

Earlier today, Judge Juan Merchan reiterated his past ruling preventing prosecutors from playing Trump’s Access Hollywood tape to the jury. But he clarified that the prosecutors could introduce the exact words that Trump said and an email related to the tape, as long as jurors do not hear the recording itself.

##Analysis#

1:28 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Here's what jurors could learn about Michael Cohen

From CNN's Kara Scannell and Jeremy Herb

Michael Cohen leaves the courtroom after testifying in the civil business fraud trail of former President Donald Trump in New York in October 2023.
Michael Cohen leaves the courtroom after testifying in the civil business fraud trail of former President Donald Trump in New York in October 2023. Alex Kent/AFP/Getty Images

Judge Juan Merchan held to his previous ruling on what prosecutors will be allowed to introduce about Michael Cohen's 2018 guilty plea to campaign finance violations. 

It's a key question because Cohen's credibility is going to be one of the biggest issues for the jury in this case. Trump's attorneys are planning to try to discredit Cohen, who is a central witness for the prosecution. And prosecutors want to include tweets Trump sent about Cohen from 2018. Those tweets include those supporting Cohen and then criticizing him after he flipped.

The judge is nuanced because he did not rule that the tweets could be introduced in the prosecution's direct case, but said it was an "academic" argument because Cohen's credibility would be raised during the defense cross-examination. Merchan reminded the prosecution that they cannot tie Cohen's guilty plea to Trump. But he will allow testimony of Cohen's guilty plea with the proper foundation.

Merchan says he can still revisit the prior ruling, but he doesn't know what's going to happen at trial. "I think this portion of the roadmap is pretty clear" about what the prosecution can and cannot do. Merchan says he does not want a jury to think that because Cohen pleaded guilty to campaign finance violations that, therefore, Trump is guilty of that, and he says the prosecution has said they are not going to argue that.

Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass had asked the judge to clarify that they can discuss Cohen's guilty plea to campaign finance violations, arguing that it shows why Cohen "changed his tune."  Trump attorney Todd Blanche argued that the former president's attorneys don't intend to bring up Cohen's guilty plea on campaign finance violations, but Merchan is skeptical about raising some of Cohen's crimes but not others. He says that can happen, but typically it involves different crimes on different days, which is not the case here.

Blanche responded that Trump "is not charged" with any campaign finance crimes, saying the robbery conspiracy example is not applicable here.

12:55 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Trump has only spoken 3 words so far into the court record

From pool reporter

On the first morning of his trial, Donald Trump has spoken just three barely audible words into the record.

He said "Yes" three times as he was read his so-called "Parker warnings," which advise defendants that they are entitled to assist in their defense by being present in court, but can lose that privilege if they voluntarily absent themselves from the trial or they are removed from court for reasons of misconduct. 

12:26 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Court is taking a lunch break

Court will be on a lunch break until 1:30 p.m. ET.

12:35 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Trump attorney argues the 3 social media posts do not violate gag order

Former President Donald Trump appears in court with his attorneys Todd Blanche, left, and Emil Bove on April 15.
Former President Donald Trump appears in court with his attorneys Todd Blanche, left, and Emil Bove on April 15. Jabin Botsford/Pool/Getty Images

Trump attorney Todd Blanche argued in court that the three Donald Trump social media posts that prosecutors are pointing to do not violate the gag order.

While the prosecutor was reading the posts, Trump could be seen leaning forward with his elbows resting on the defense table.

Blanche said the witnesses frequently make statements about Trump. "It’s not as if President Trump is going off and targeting individuals. He’s responding to salacious repeated .. attacks by these witnesses," the attorney argued.

The judge is yet to rule on the matter.

12:25 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Prosecutor: Trump is a criminal defendant and subject to court supervision

"We think that it is important for the court to remind Mr. Trump that he is a criminal defendant. And like all criminal defendants he’s subject to court supervision," Prosecutor Chris Conroy says.

1:28 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Judge is allowing some evidence and testimony that was previously challenged in Trump's criminal trial

From CNN's Kara Scannell and Jeremy Herb

Here's what evidence is allowed:

  • Karen McDougal’s testimony will be allowed: Judge Juan Merchan ruled he will allow testimony of Karen McDougal, who alleged she also had an affair with Donald Trump, but limited the scope of what she can say in her testimony. Merchan said it is not necessary for the jury to hear that Trump continued his affair with McDougal while his wife, Melania Trump, was pregnant and after she gave birth. Trump attorney Todd Blanche unsuccessfully argued that including discussion of McDougal's arrangement with American Media Inc. is not part of the charges against Trump. The district attorney's office has argued the AMI deal, along with the Stormy Daniels hush money payments, shows a pattern.

National Enquirer stories attacking Trump’s opponents will be allowed: Merchan will allow a series of stories from National Enquirer that attacked Trump's opponents during the 2016 election cycle to be used as evidence. He noted that the district attorney's office has demonstrated there was an understanding that certain things would be done and wouldn't be done at AMI, which owned the National Enquirer. The National Enquirer stories were the result of an August 2015 meeting at Trump Tower among David Pecker, Michael Cohen and Trump where they devised the “catch and kill” plan to help Trump.

12:23 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Prosecutors are introducing a motion to sanction Trump for social media posts

Prosecutors are introducing a motion to sanction Donald Trump for his social media posts they allege violate the judge's gag order.

Prosecutor Chris Conroy told the judge they are seeking permission to hold Trump in contempt for violating the gag order and sanction Trump $1,000 for each of the three posts that violate the order.

Conroy also said that prosecutors want the judge to take down the three posts and to remind the defendant that "further violations could result in jail time."

They also note they want to include his post from this morning, too.

He said it was posted at 9:12 a.m. this morning and it is "entirely possible that it was done while in this courthouse."