Judge excuses potential juror who says she has firmly held beliefs about Trump

Day 1 of Trump New York hush money trial

By Kara Scannell, Jeremy Herb, Maureen Chowdhury, Kaanita Iyer, Aditi Sangal and Elise Hammond, CNN

Updated 9:30 a.m. ET, April 22, 2024
104 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
3:39 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Judge excuses potential juror who says she has firmly held beliefs about Trump

The third prospective juror answered "yes" when she was asked, "Do you have firmly held beliefs about Trump, or that he's a current candidate, that would interfere in your ability to be fair?"

Lawyers had a sidebar at the bench after she answered. Afterward, the judge announced the potential juror would be excused.

Trump remained seated during the sidebar.

3:44 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

More potential jurors lost on impartiality question than Trump team was expecting, sources tell CNN

Donald Trump's team was expecting around 40% of jurors to be dismissed on the question of whether they can be impartial, sources told CNN's Paula Reid, but more than half of the first group of 96 prospective jurors were reportedly excused after that question was asked.

"They're going to preserve this issue on appeal," Reid said. "Their concern is if Trump is convicted, right, that is a concern, their strategy is to appeal this and preserve every single issue, and try to kill the case."

Trump's lawyers fought to have this question separated, Reid reported. They did not want to have all the potential jurors who can't serve to be lumped in as one so they could establish how many people cannot be impartial.

3:29 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Trump is reading along with his own copy of the jury questionnaire

From pool reports

Voir dire has begun, according to pool reports, and a young woman has started answering the jury questionnaire.

Donald Trump is reading along with her as she answers, with his own copy.

The judge last week released the questionnaire that will be presented to potential jurors. It includes questions about a potential juror's news consumption and whether they've read any of Trump's books.

3:27 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Judge is moving on to juror questions

Judge Juan Merchan poses for a picture in his chambers in New York, in March.
Judge Juan Merchan poses for a picture in his chambers in New York, in March. Seth Wenig/AP

Judge Juan Merchan is now moving on to juror questions.

The judge last week released the questionnaire that will be presented to potential jurors, which contains multiple questions that could signal political views to the lawyers on both sides.

Here's what potential jurors could be asked about:

  • News consumption.
  • Affiliations with groups like the Proud Boys, QAnon and Antifa.
  • Whether they or anyone in their circle attended a Trump rally or an anti-Trump event.
  • If they’ve ever read books or listened to podcasts from Michael Cohen, Trump’s former lawyer and a key witness for the district attorney.
  • If they’ve read any of Trump’s own books.
  • If they have views on whether a former president can be charged in state court.
  • If they have views on how Trump is being treated in this case.

3:34 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Prospective juror group continues to dwindle after more individuals say they can't serve for other reasons

At least nine more prospective jurors were excused in the first group after raising their hand when Judge Merchan asked if they could not serve for any other reason.

Those reasons were not disclosed.

That leaves approximately 34 jurors out of the 96 who entered court in the initial panel.

3:12 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

18 potential jurors have been called into the jury box

A group of 18 potential jurors have been called into the jury box.

3:18 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

More than half of 96 prospective jurors let go from first panel after saying they couldn't be fair and impartial

More than half of the prospective jurors in the first batch of 96 people have been excused after saying that they couldn't be fair and impartial. The press pool estimates at least 50 people were let go for that reason. 

Judge Juan Merchan asked potential jurors to raise their hands if they believed they cannot be fair and impartial. He then began excusing those jurors one by one.

3:18 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

"Please raise your hand if you're unable to serve on this jury for any other reason," judge asks potential jurors

Judge Juan Merchan has moved on to his second question for potential jurors.

He asked the jury pool, "Please raise your hand if you’re unable to serve on this jury for any other reason."

3:16 p.m. ET, April 15, 2024

Judge to prospective jurors: Please let me know If you cannot be "fair and impartial" in the trial

"If you have an honest, legitimate, good-faith reason to believe you cannot serve on this case or cannot be fair and impartial, please let me know now," Judge Juan Merchan told the prospective jurors.