Negotiations over hostages continue despite resumed fighting, source says

December 1, 2023 Israel-Hamas war

By Tara Subramaniam, Helen Regan, Christian Edwards, Ed Upright, Adrienne Vogt, Matt Meyer, Zoe Sottile and Elise Hammond, CNN

Updated 4:05 a.m. ET, December 3, 2023
12 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
1:47 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Negotiations over hostages continue despite resumed fighting, source says

From CNN's MJ Lee, Alex Marquardt and Becky Anderson

Negotiations with Qatari and Egyptian mediators over the release of hostages held by Hamas in Gaza are still ongoing, a source familiar with the talks told CNN, even after Israel’s military announced the resumption of combat operations in Gaza early Friday. 

An hour past the 7 a.m. local time expiration of the truce, none of the main parties involved – Hamas, Qatar, Israel, the US or Egypt – had publicly declared a breakdown in the talks.

Negotiations had been aimed at extending the seven-day pause in the war.

Under the terms of a previously struck agreement, Hamas had been expected to propose an eighth list of hostages — 10 women and children to be released on Friday in exchange for an extra day of pause.

Israel has demanded that Hamas release women and children, alive, before moving on to other groups of hostages.

Israel had warned that full-scale military operations would resume once the current phase of hostage releases ends. But US officials have said talks will continue regardless to free the remaining hostages.

This post has been updated with additional information.

1:16 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Analysis: US seeks to reshape Israel’s war on Hamas

Analysis from CNN's Stephen Collinson

Hours before Israel said it had resumed combat operations against Hamas, the United States pressured its ally to shield Palestinian civilians in one of the most significant diplomatic moves yet in the more than 50-day conflict.

The question now, if a seven-day truce is permanently broken, is whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government is prepared to listen.

Secretary of State Antony Blinken laid out American requirements both at a televised press conference in Tel Aviv and in private talks in Jerusalem with Netanyahu and his war cabinet.

“I underscored the imperative of the United States that the massive loss of civilian life and displacement of the scale that we saw in Northern Gaza not be repeated in the South," Blinken said hours before the lapsing of a seven-day pause in the fighting.
“I made clear that before Israel resumes major military operations, it must put in place humanitarian civilian protection plans that minimize further casualties of innocent Palestinians,” Blinken added, specifically mentioning the need to safeguard hospitals, powers stations and facilities.

Blinken's frank tone suggests that the White House is not completely buying Israel’s assurances that it takes every possible step to alleviate civilian casualties in its response to the October 7 Hamas terror attack that killed 1,200 people.

Blinken noted bluntly, for instance, that he told Netanyahu: “Intent matters. But so does the result.”

Blinken said that Netanyahu had agreed to take steps to protect civilians. But two key questions now will be whether those efforts are genuine and effective and to what extent the Israeli prime minister and his military brass are willing to accommodate US concerns.

Read more about the US approach here.

1:56 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Israeli strikes resume across Gaza, Hamas-controlled ministry says

From CNN’s Kareem El Damanhoury and Ibrahim Dahman

Smoke from Gaza is seen rising from buildings after being hit by Israeli strikes on Friday.
Smoke from Gaza is seen rising from buildings after being hit by Israeli strikes on Friday. John MacDougall/AFP/Getty Images

Israeli strikes have resumed in areas across Gaza, according to a statement from the Hamas-controlled Ministry of Interior.

It follows the break down of a week-long truce between Israel and Hamas on Friday.

An earlier statement from the ministry said that strikes had landed in southern Gaza, in the areas of Khan Younis and Rafah.

The ministry also noted earlier that Israeli military vehicles were firing in northwest Gaza minutes after the truce expired.

12:31 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Israeli military active in northern Gaza, Hamas-controlled ministry says as truce breaks down

From CNN’s Kareem El Damanhoury

Minutes after a week-long truce between Israel and Hamas broke down on Friday, Israeli military vehicles were firing in northwest Gaza, according to the Hamas-controlled Ministry of Interior in Gaza.

In a statement, the ministry also said Israeli aircraft were in the skies above the area.

The statement from Hamas comes as the Israeli military said it had resumed combat operations against the militant group, accusing it of violating the truce agreement by firing toward Israel.

12:34 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Breaking: Israeli military says it has resumed combat operations against Hamas 

From Tamar Michaelis

IDF tanks gather on the border with Gaza on Thursday.
IDF tanks gather on the border with Gaza on Thursday. Gil Cohen-Magen/AFP/Getty Images/Filee

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) says it has resumed combat operations against Hamas, accusing the militant group of violating the truce agreement by firing toward Israel.

12:03 a.m. ET, December 1, 2023

Breaking: Israel-Hamas truce agreement appears to have expired with no immediate sign of extension

From CNN staff

The truce between Israel and Hamas appeared to have expired Friday with no immediate sign of an agreement being reached to further extend the hostage deal to an eighth day.  

It is not yet clear whether this means that fighting will resume in the Gaza Strip, which suffered extensive damage and loss of life during seven weeks of Israeli bombardment. 

An hour before Friday’s deadline was set to expire Israel’s aerial defense system intercepted one rocket launched from the Gaza Strip, the Israeli military said. There was no indication of who launched the single rocket. 

The truce, which started last Friday, was expected to expire at 7 a.m. local time (12 a.m. ET). An agreement to extend to a seventh day came down to the wire on Thursday. 

Some context: Egyptian and Qatari negotiators had been pushing to extend the pause in fighting in Gaza for an extra two days to facilitate the release of further hostages and Palestinian prisoners, and to allow more aid into the strip, according to Egypt's State Information Service. 

Israeli officials have repeatedly stated that a condition of any extension to the pause in fighting is that Hamas must release 10 Israeli women and children held hostage per day.  

Under the terms of the deal, Israel freed three Palestinians for every Israeli hostage released.  

As the truce expiration loomed both Israel and Hamas have indicated they’re prepared for fighting to resume.

“We should be prepared for a quick transition into full scale fighting at any point, today, tomorrow, at any moment. As soon as we maximize the move to return hostages we will resume fierce fighting across the whole Gaza Strip,” Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said Thursday.

Hamas’ military wing on Thursday asked its forces to maintain a high-combat readiness posture.

In the seven-day pause in fighting, 80 Israelis — primarily women and children and some of whom are dual citizens — and another 24 foreign nationals have been released. Another Israeli dual citizen was also freed outside of the agreed-upon deal. 

As of Thursday, 240 Palestinians had been freed from Israeli prisons — mainly women and minors.  

11:40 p.m. ET, November 30, 2023

Truce agreement between Israel and Hamas is set to expire. Here's where things stand

From CNN staff

An uneasy truce between Israel and Hamas that has lasted for seven days is set to expire again at around 7 a.m. local time Friday (midnight ET).

Just over an hour before the truce was set to expire, the Israeli military said its air defense system intercepted one rocket launched from Gaza.

The pause in fighting has brought temporary respite to those in the besieged enclave of Gaza and led to the release of dozens of hostages, the freeing of Palestinians from Israeli jails and the ratcheting up of much-needed humanitarian supplies to the strip.

The truce, which started last Friday, was only renewed at the last minute for the seventh day on Thursday after a tense and lengthy back-and-forth.

Both sides are in a day-to-day extension phase of the agreement under which Hamas must offer up a new list of 10 hostages to be released to secure another 24 hours in the pause in fighting. 

The military wing of Hamas is calling for its forces to remain on “high combat readiness” in case combat resumes, a statement said.

Here's what you should know to get up to speed:

  • Released hostages and prisoners: Hamas released eight hostages on Thursday, including two minors and six women of dual nationality. The seventh group was released at different times because they were held in different locations in Gaza, an Israeli official said. According to sources, to extend the truce, Israel accepted eight new hostages plus the two Israeli-Russians released on Wednesday. Meanwhile, a total of 30 Palestinians were released from Israeli prisons on Thursday, the Israeli prison service said.
  • Status of the truce: Egyptian and Qatari negotiators are pushing to extend the truce for an additional two days, Egypt said. Under Thursday's extension, which was agreed upon minutes before the truce was set to expire, 10 Israeli hostages and 30 Palestinian prisoners were to be released — the same terms as the previous days.
  • Negotiation challenges: But continuing to extend the pause in fighting could be challenging, negotiators said. Hamas claimed until the last minute that it was having trouble locating 10 women and children hostages — a condition that Israel insisted must be met — to extend the truce into Thursday. A member of Israel's parliament said the government is willing to discuss different terms for the release of men and soldiers held by the militant group.
  • Climate summit sidelines: Israeli President Isaac Herzog is asking United Arab Emirates President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan to use his “full political weight” to help speed up the release of remaining hostages in Gaza. The leaders met on the sidelines of the UN climate summit COP28 in Dubai, according to a readout of the meeting.
  • Blinken visit: US Secretary of State Antony Blinken met separately with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the war cabinet and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas on Thursday. The top US diplomat said Netanyahu offered concrete steps to ensure Israel makes further efforts to protect civilians in Gaza when fighting resumes. Blinken also “condemned extremist violence against Palestinian civilians in the West Bank and said he would continue to insist on full accountability for those responsible” in his meeting with Abbas.
  • ICC chief in Israel: The International Criminal Court's chief prosecutor visited Israel at the request of survivors and families of victims of the October 7 attacks. The court said Karim Khan's visit was "not investigative in nature." Five countries have submitted a referral to the ICC to investigate whether crimes have been committed in the Palestinian territories as part of Israel’s response to the Hamas attacks.

11:07 p.m. ET, November 30, 2023

Israeli military intercepts rocket launched from Gaza shortly before truce is set to expire

From CNN staff

The Israeli military's air defense system intercepted one rocket launched from the Gaza Strip just over an hour before the truce between Israel and Hamas is set to expire, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said early Friday local time.

There is no indication of who launched the single rocket.

Rocket sirens have been heard in the Sderot area in the final hours of the seven-day truce.  

The current agreement between Israel and Hamas is set to expire at 7 a.m. local time Friday (midnight ET).

This post has been updated with additional information.

11:07 p.m. ET, November 30, 2023

Israel was aware of Hamas’ attack plan over a year ago, New York Times reports

From CNN's Simone McCarthy

Palestinian militants ride an Israeli military vehicle that was seized by gunmen who infiltrated areas of southern Israel on October 7.
Palestinian militants ride an Israeli military vehicle that was seized by gunmen who infiltrated areas of southern Israel on October 7. Ahmed Zakot/Reuters

Israeli officials obtained a document describing Hamas’ battle plan for its October 7 terror attack more than a year before the militant group carried out the assault, the New York Times reported Thursday, citing documents, emails and interviews. 

The roughly 40-page document did not give a date for the attack, but outlined “point by point” the kind of deadly incursion that Hamas carried out in Israeli territory in October, according to the Times, which reviewed the translated document.

Israeli military and intelligence officials dismissed the plan, assessing that it would be too difficult for Hamas to carry out, according to the Times.

The document, which the Israeli authorities code-named “Jericho Wall,” detailed an assault that would overwhelm fortifications around the Gaza Strip, take over Israeli cities and target key military bases. It was followed with precision by Hamas on October 7, the Times said.

On that day, Hamas militants struck across the border from Gaza in a coordinated assault taking more than 200 hostages and killing around 1,200 people – the largest such attack on Israel since the country’s founding in 1948. 

The attack was widely seen a major Israeli intelligence failure, with a number of top defense and security officials coming forward in October to take responsibility to some extent for missteps that led to the attacks. 

Later that month, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu received sharp public criticism after he accused security chiefs in a later-deleted social media post of failing to warn him about the impending attack.

“On the contrary, all the defense officials … assessed that Hamas was deterred,” Netanyahu wrote at the time.

According to the Times, the “Jericho Wall” document was circulated widely among Israeli military and intelligence leaders, but it was unclear whether Netanyahu or other top political leaders saw the document.