Seated jury down to 6 after juror says aspects of her identity were made public. Here's what happened in court

Day 3 of Trump New York hush money trial

From CNN's Jeremy Herb, Lauren del Valle and Kara Scannell in the courthouse

Updated 8:02 p.m. ET, April 18, 2024
31 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
10:20 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Seated jury down to 6 after juror says aspects of her identity were made public. Here's what happened in court

A juror sworn onto Donald Trump's jury panel Tuesday was dismissed Thursday morning after expressing concerns that part of her identity were made public by the media.

There are now six jurors empaneled. Juror No. 2 told Judge Juan Merchan:

"Aspects of my identity have already been out there in the public, yesterday alone I had friends colleagues and family push things to my phone questioning my identity as a juror," she said.

The juror’s concerns reflected the historic nature of the case and the intense pressure in a polarized political climate that will be on the panel of people who are called to do their civic duty to be fair and impartial.

Merchan then addressed the press in court, telling them "there's a reason this is an anonymous jury."

"We just lost what probably would've been a very good juror," Merchan said. The judge said the juror said she was "afraid" and felt intimated by the press.

Merchan said he agrees with the defense that it's important to obtain information about prospective jurors' employers. But he says he is going to have those answers to questions 3a and 3d redacted from the court record, and he is directing the press in the courtroom and in the overflow not to report those answers.

"It’s become a problem," Merchan says.

Questions 3a and 3d ask: Who is your current employer and who is your previous employer?

While having an empaneled juror excused is not common, the juror's concern about aspects of her identity being revealed is a byproduct of a high profile case with a lot of publicity.

9:43 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Judge rules media cannot publish jurors' answers to question about employers

Judge Juan Merchan ruled media outlets cannot publish the jurors' answers to question 3 on the questionnaire. It will also be redacted from the transcripts.

Questions 3a and 3d ask: "Who is your current employer and who is your previous employer?"

9:38 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Trump attorney suggests judge tell media to not publish where jurors work

Donald Trump attorney Todd Blanche suggested that Judge Juan Merchan instruct members of the press not to publish where potential jurors work.

Merchan is considering the options now. He hasn't ruled yet.

9:37 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Trump's legal team pushes back on prosecutor's suggestion that jurors not name their employers

Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass suggested they direct the jurors not to announce the company where they are employed.

Judge Juan Merchan liked the idea, but former President Donald Trump’s team pushed back. Trump attorney Susan Necheles said, “It’s the government’s fault we don’t have a written questionnaire. We knew this would be a problem.”

9:35 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Judge urges press to not describe physical appearances of jurors after paneled juror is excused 

After a paneled juror expressed concerns in court about her ability to serve, Judge Juan Merchan addressed the press in court, telling them "there's a reason this is an anonymous jury."

"I'm directing that the press simply apply common sense and refrain from writing about anything that has to do with physical descriptions, it's just not necessary, it serves no purpose," the judge said.

"We just lost what probably would've been a very good juror," Merchan said. "The first thing she said was she was afraid and intimidating by the press."

9:32 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Juror is excused

The juror says that she has concerns because "aspects of my identity" have been out there and she's concerned she will not be able to act fair and impartial.

"Yesterday alone, I had friends colleagues and family push things to my phone questioning my identity as a juror," she said.

She is excused.

9:31 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Trump campaign spokesperson and ally are in court today

Trump ally Jason Miller and Trump campaign spokesperson Steven Cheung are seated inside the courtroom, according to reports from journalists in court.

9:31 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Judge is speaking with juror

The juror is now speaking with Judge Juan Merchan, who is questioning her.

9:30 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024

Empaneled juror expressed concerns about her ability to be fair

One of the empaneled jurors called the court expressing concerns about her ability to be fair and impartial. The court asked her to come in to discuss further.

She is here today, and she will enter the courtroom momentarily.