Defense team raises potential juror's Facebook posts from yesterday

Day 2 of Trump New York hush money trial

By CNN's Lauren del Valle and Jeremy Herb in court

Updated 11:24 a.m. ET, April 18, 2024
133 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
3:09 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Defense team raises potential juror's Facebook posts from yesterday

Donald Trump's team is now challenging potential juror No. 6.

Judge Juan Merchan read a social media post Trump's team flagged from the juror.

"Want to beat Trump in 2024?" Merchan read the post in part. There's also a photo of display tables with a Biden-Harris poster on it.

Trump attorney Todd Blanche also raised two social media posts on Facebook from yesterday from this juror, where he was asked if he got picked and he said, "I have to go back tomorrow."

3:04 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Merchan declines to dismiss prospective juror over husband's social media posts

Judge Juan Merchan declines to dismiss a potential juror for cause or bring her in for questioning.

"These are posts from over 8 years ago, not involving the juror, involving the juror’s husband," he says.

"Honestly, if this is the worst thing that you were able to find about this juror — that her husband posted this humor, albeit not very good humor, from 8 years ago — it gives me confidence this juror can be fair," Merchan says.

"I'm not going to make further inquiry," Merchan said.

Former President Donald Trump is leaning back in his chair. He turned to his lawyer Emil Bove and made a remark when Merchan made that ruling.

3:01 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Social posts are jokes and do not indicate bias, prosecutor says

Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass said that the social media posts in question are jokes and not an indication of bias.

"It is not necessarily as weighty as it's being suggested," he says.

3:02 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Judge tired of Trump team approach of challenging multiple social media posts of jurors

Judge Juan Merchan is starting to get tired of the approach of former President Donald Trump's attorneys of challenging every juror's social media posts.

Merchan said the court is not going to keep doing this. "If you have the goods on someone you need to politely and respectfully" ask them about it, he said.

Merchan notes that Trump attorney Todd Blanche could have asked this juror about her family member's posts during "voir dire," the earlier portion of questioning.

2:59 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Trump's team challenging 3rd potential juror for social media memes

Donald Trump's team is now challenging juror No. 3.

Defense attorney Todd Blanche raised three social media posts of memes. One of the posts is a picture of Trump and Obama from 2016, with the caption: "I don’t think this is what they meant when they said orange is the new black."

2:57 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Judge points to "lock him up" language in social post

Judge Juan Merchan says that the potential juror's social media post about the travel ban being unlawful was acceptable, but it also contained the language "lock him up."

"This is a person who expressed ... a desire that Donald Trump be locked up," Merchan says, even though he notes that it was a few years ago.

Merchan read the post: "Goodness !! Trump lost his court battle on his unlawful travel ban!!"

"If it ended there, I wouldn’t really have a major problem with it," the judge said. "Then it continues 'get him out' and 'lock him up.'"

Merchan said "everyone knows" there's a potential jail sentence for Trump if he's convicted, so he could be "locked up."

2:55 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Judge strikes potential juror for cause

The judge is striking potential juror No. 2 for cause.

Trump's team found social media posts from the juror referencing Trump that say, “Get him out” and “Lock him up."

2:53 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Potential juror on social posts about Trump: I can set all feelings aside

The prospective juror whose Facebook posts are in question said he can "set all the prior feelings aside" about the former president.

2:52 p.m. ET, April 16, 2024

Potential juror doesn't remember posting about Trump on social media

The potential juror being questioned now was a middle-aged man who lives in Midtown and works as a creative director.

The juror confirmed the social media account in question is his.

Trump attorney Todd Blanche asked whether he has recollection of this post. The man said he does not but it's on his account so it's his post.