Netanyahu pushes back on criticism of civilian casualties in Gaza

October 30, 2023 - Israel-Hamas war news

By Tara Subramaniam, Christian Edwards, Ed Upright, Aditi Sangal, Mike Hayes, Elise Hammond, Holly Yan, Zoe Sottile and Maureen Chowdhury, CNN

Updated 1:08 p.m. ET, October 31, 2023
41 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
2:32 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

Netanyahu pushes back on criticism of civilian casualties in Gaza

From CNN's Kyle Blaine

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pushed back against the notion that Israel was inflicting collective punishment on the Palestinian people in its pursuit of Hamas, saying the group was preventing civilians from moving to the safe zone in southern Gaza. 

“Hamas is preventing them from leaving, keeping them in areas of conflict. So I think you should direct your questions to Hamas,” Netanyahu told a reporter at a news conference Monday. 

Netanyahu said Israel has been trying to prevent civilian casualties by calling for civilians in Gaza to move to a safe zone in the south and providing humanitarian support. 

“We have to do everything we can to minimize civilian causalities, but we cannot give up the fight,” Netanyahu said, saying the future of his countries and other “civilized countries” depend on it. 

3:37 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

Netanyahu: "This is a time for war"

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends a press conference at the Kirya military base in Tel Aviv on October 28.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends a press conference at the Kirya military base in Tel Aviv on October 28. Abir Sultan/Pool/AFP/Getty Images

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made clear on Monday that Israel would not agree to a ceasefire, drawing parallels to the United States’ position after Pearl Harbor in 1941 and the September 11 attacks in 2001. 

“I want to make clear Israel's position regarding the ceasefire. Just as the United States would not agree to a ceasefire after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, or after the terrorist attacks of 9/11. Israel will not agree to a cessation of hostilities with Hamas after the horrific attacks of October 7,” he said. 

“Calls for a ceasefire or calls for Israel to surrender to Hamas, to surrender to terrorists, surrender to barbarism, that will not happen,” he added. 

Netanyahu said while the Bible says there is a time for peace, he said “This is a time for war.” 

When asked if he has considered stepping down, Netanyahu said the only thing he would resign is Hamas. 

“We're going to resign them to the dustbin of history. That's my goal. That's my responsibility,” he said. 

Meanwhile, a Hamas spokesperson said Monday that Israel was not successful in entering Gaza "except in some limited areas" and described the humanitarian situation in the enclave as "disastrous."

Watch part of Netanyahu's address here:

CNN’s Pierre Meilhan contributed reporting to this post.

2:29 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

150 aid trucks have crossed into Gaza since the gate opened last week, US says

From CNN's Michael Conte

A total number of 150 aid trucks that have made it through the Rafah crossing into Gaza since the gate opened last week, according to the US State Department.

A total of 45 aid trucks went through on Sunday — the most since the gate opened, it added.

“We aim to surpass that number today, tomorrow and beyond,” said State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller.

Miller said the US would “continue our relentless diplomatic efforts in partnership with Israel, Egypt, the United Nations and international humanitarian partners” to increase “daily deliveries of food, water and medical supplies into Gaza.” 

Some context: Prior to October 7, there were 450 trucks going into Gaza daily, said Lynn Hastings, the UN Humanitarian co-ordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory, in a press briefing last week. She said the trucks were facing delays due to screening, technical, security and political issues.

3:43 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

New Israeli leaflets dropped on Gaza urge civilians to evacuate a "battlefield"

From CNN's Ibrahim Dahman and Eyad Kourdi

An IDF leaflet dropped in Gaza warning civilians to evacuate is seen on Monday.
An IDF leaflet dropped in Gaza warning civilians to evacuate is seen on Monday. Obtained by CN

Israeli aircraft have dropped new leaflets in Arabic over Gaza, warning people in northern and central parts of the strip that “the governorate of Gaza has become a battlefield.”

“Shelters in the north of the Gaza Strip and the governorate of Gaza have become unsafe,” according to the leaflet, an image of which has been seen by CNN. 

“Hamas and the terrorist organizations are using the shelters, hospitals and schools in this area. Therefore, your presence in these places is not safe,” the flier continued.

“You must immediately evacuate and move to the humanitarian area to the south of Wadi Gaza,” the leaflet concluded, referring to a waterway that bisects the enclave.

1:14 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

McConnell continues to push tying Ukraine and Israel aid despite House GOP push for standalone Israel package

From CNN's Morgan Rimmer

Mitch McConnell speaks to reporters at the Capitol Building on October 24.
Mitch McConnell speaks to reporters at the Capitol Building on October 24.

US Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell continues to advocate for linking Ukraine and Israel aid together despite a House GOP push for a standalone Israel package offset by cuts, a sign of the division within the most senior Republicans.

“This is a moment for swift and decisive action to prevent further loss of life and to impose real consequences on the tyrants who have terrorized the people of Ukraine and of Israel. And right now, the Senate has a chance to produce supplemental assistance that will help us do exactly that,” said McConnell while introducing Ukrainian Ambassador Oksana Markarova at an event in Louisville, Kentucky on Monday.

“Enemies abroad will be watching closely and waiting for America to falter. Only our concrete and credible support can deter our adversaries in the future, and restore security,” he said.

McConnell tied aggression against Israel and Ukraine together, telling attendees: “Think of it as an axis of evil: China, Russia, and Iran. So this is not just a test for Ukraine. It is a test for the United States and for the free world. And the path toward greater security for all of us is simple: help Ukraine win the war.”

McConnell pushed back on the members of his own party who have argued against further aid for Ukraine.

“Some say our support for Ukraine comes at the expense of more important priorities. But as I say every time I’ve got the chance, this is a false choice,” he said. “If Russia prevails, there’s no question that Putin’s appetite for empire will actually extend into NATO, raising the threat to the U.S. trans-Atlantic alliance, and the risk of war for us.”

 

1:03 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

10 UN workers killed in Gaza the last 72 hours, bringing total to 63, relief agency says

From CNN’s Niamh Kennedy in London and Ben Wedeman in Beirut

In just the past three days, 10 United Nations staff members have been killed in Gaza, the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) said Monday. 

That brings the total number of UNRWA staff killed in Gaza since October 7 to 63, the agency said. 

The UNRWA, which runs the “largest humanitarian operation” in the Gaza Strip, also described dire conditions at its network of schools that are sheltering displaced Gazans.

“The average number of IDPs (internally displaced persons) per shelter has almost reached four times their intended capacity,” UNRWA added. 

Overcrowded conditions “create severe health and protection concerns for IDPs and place a “heavy toll on their mental health,” the agency stressed. 

More than 511,000 people are sheltering in 92 shelters — an increase of about 13,000 internally displaced persons since the UNRWA's last update. 

Several incidents of collateral damage to UNRWA premises have also been observed in the past 72 hours, the agency said. 

8:58 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

Hamas releases new hostage video showing 3 women 

From CNN’s Eyad Kourdi, Lianne Kolirin, Amir Tal, Hadas Gold and Adam Levine

Hamas Monday released a short video showing three women who are believed to be captives held by the Palestinian militant group since its terror attack on Israel on October 7.

The hostage video is only the second released by Hamas since more than 200 people were taken into Gaza after the attack earlier this month and appears intended undermine Benjamin Netanyahu with pointed criticism over his leadership by the detained women.

The video shows them seated in plastic chairs facing the camera, while the woman in the middle addresses Netanyahu directly with increasing fury. 

She makes reference to a press conference by families of the hostages “yesterday,” suggesting it was filmed on Monday.

The video comes just days after progress in hostage negotiations fell through, a fact referenced by the speaker who mentions a supposed “ceasefire.” Israeli leaders Friday dismissed talks of a breakthrough in talks as a rumor as they announced an expansion of the ground campaign.

The woman speaks fluently and does not appear to be reading from a script, but because the women are hostages, the statement could have been made under duress. 

“You promised to release us all,” she says, suggesting she is aware of hostage negotiations. 

She finishes with a demand to “free us all,” screaming: “Now! Now! Now!”

Relatives of the hostages have named the women as Yelena Trupanob, Daniel Aloni and Rimon Kirsht; Aloni is the speaker. 

The women do not show visible signs of physical mistreatment, but CNN is unable to verify anything about their circumstances or well-being. 

Netanyahu’s office confirmed the names in a brief statement, and said, "Our hearts go out to you and the other abductees. We are doing everything to bring all the kidnapped and missing people home."

Israeli television channels 11 and 12 are showing a still from the video on air. Channel 13 is not, saying on air it is honoring a request from the relatives.

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) commented on the Hamas hostage video, with Israeli military spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari saying in a press briefing Monday that "our heart is broken by the cry of Daniel and from the faces of Yelena and Rimon who sit beside her."

Hagari said Hamas is engaging in "mindgames" by releasing the footage of the women, and noted the number of hostages believed to held by the Palestinian militant group in Gaza is 238. 

Translation by Ido Soen in London. CNN's Stephanie Halasz, Richard Allen Greene and Abel Alvarado contributed to this post.

Correction: The post has been updated with the correct spelling of the names of the hostages shown in the video.

12:05 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

26 aid trucks arrive in Gaza from Egyptian side of Rafah crossing

From Asmaa Khalil in Rafah and CNN’s Zeena Saifi in Jerusalem

 

Twenty-six aid trucks have passed inspection and made their way to the Gaza Strip from Egypt, according to a CNN stringer at the Rafah border crossing

Meanwhile, 34 trucks are still undergoing security checks, and 15 remain to be inspected.

Remember: Rafah crossing, the border crossing between Gaza and Egypt, has been touted as the last hope for Gazans to escape as Israel’s bombs rain down. It is, however, shut to the movement of people. Only aid has been allowed in the recent days. 

12:13 p.m. ET, October 30, 2023

"We cannot cope": Palestinian doctor describes chaotic scenes inside Gaza's largest hospital

From CNN's Vasco Cotovio and Abeer Salman

Bodies of Palestinians killed by an explosion at the Al-Ahli Hospital are gathered in the front yard of the Al-Shifa hospital, in Gaza City on October 17.
Bodies of Palestinians killed by an explosion at the Al-Ahli Hospital are gathered in the front yard of the Al-Shifa hospital, in Gaza City on October 17. Abed Khaled/AP

The head of surgery at Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza — the enclave’s largest — says staff at the facility “cannot cope” with the huge number of patients they are treating, as he shared video of the chaotic scenes inside the hospital’s emergency ward. 

The video he recorded and sent to CNN shows several rows of patients lining both sides of a hospital corridor, some on stretchers, others simply lying on the floor. 

“This is the yellow area of our emergency department at the Shifa medical complex. Injured people there, there, there…,” Dr. Marwan Sai’ida says as he pans the camera, covering the entire length of the corridor. “[We are] overrun with patients, huge number of injured people.”

Like most specialists at the hospital, he says he is now just working in the emergency ward to help treat the many wounded that continue to arrive. 

“[It is] difficult to cope with this situation, this is horrible, the staff cannot cope with this huge number of injured people,” he says, “There’s no more space.”

Sai’ida, who is also the head of International Cooperation at the Palestinian Ministry of Health, says there are currently 8,000 people at the hospital, and called on global leaders to act to end the war.