5 takeaways from Xi and Putin's talks in Moscow

March 22, 2023 - Russia-Ukraine news

By Tara Subramaniam, Joshua Berlinger, Aditi Sangal, Mike Hayes, Elise Hammond and Tori Powell, CNN

Updated 12:44 a.m. ET, March 23, 2023
17 Posts
Sort byDropdown arrow
6:14 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

5 takeaways from Xi and Putin's talks in Moscow

From CNN's Simone McCarthy in Hong Kong

Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin hold talks at the Kremlin on Tuesday.
Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin hold talks at the Kremlin on Tuesday. (Shen Hong/Xinhua/Getty Images)

Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin have made a sweeping affirmation of their alignment across a host of issues — and shared mistrust of the United States — in a lengthy statement following talks between the two leaders in Moscow this week.

Their meeting, which took place under the shadow of Russia’s onslaught in Ukraine, left no question about Beijing’s commitment to developing its rapport with Moscow, despite Putin’s growing isolation on the global stage as its devastating war continues into its second year.

Here's five takeaways:

  1. No meaningful path forward on Ukraine: The meetings yielded no breakthrough on resolving the conflict. Both leaders called for the cessation of actions that “increase tensions” and “prolong” the war, according to their joint statement released by China’s Foreign Ministry. The statement did not acknowledge that Russia’s invasion and military assault were the cause of ongoing violence and the humanitarian crisis in Ukraine.
  2. New world order and alignment against the US: Experts say China and Russia’s inclination to build their alignment against the US — and a world order more suited to their own more autocratic agendas — was driving the meeting, not interest in resolving the war in Ukraine. As Xi left the Kremlin following a state dinner on Tuesday with Putin, his parting message reiterated his view that global power dynamics are shifting. “Together, we should push forward these changes that have not happened for 100 years. Take care,” he said during a goodbye handshake with Putin, alluding to what Xi sees as an era where the West is fading and China is ascendant.
  3. "Military mutual trust" and defense ties: Perceived threats from bodies like NATO and AUKUS — a security pact comprised of Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States — emerged as clear focus for both leaders, including their implications on Asia. Xi and Putin both expressed “serious concerns” in their joint statement about NATO’s “continuous strengthening of military-security ties with Asia-Pacific countries” and said they “oppose external military forces undermining regional peace and stability.”
  4. Economic and energy boost: Putin said Tuesday that Moscow was ready to support Chinese business “replacing Western enterprises” that left Russia since the start of his invasion of Ukraine. Russia has grown increasingly reliant on China as both an import market and an exporter of electronics after being slapped with sweeping sanctions.
  5. Divided world: The optics of the Moscow summit was a deep contrast to the coinciding meeting in Ukraine between President Volodymyr Zelensky and Japanese leader Fumio Kishida . Zelensky praised Kishida and other leaders who have visited as “showing respect” not only for Ukraine but “for the preservation and functioning of civilized rules and civilized life in the world.”

Read more here.

4:22 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Russia warns US of "countermeasures" against Black Sea drone flights after fighter jet intercept

From CNN’s Anna Chernova

A Russian SU-27 jet is seen intercepting a US drone over the Black Sea.
A Russian SU-27 jet is seen intercepting a US drone over the Black Sea. (US European Command)

Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov has warned the United States that Moscow would take "countermeasures" against any further drone flights over part of the Black Sea following an incident last week in which a Russian jet intercepted a US drone, state media reported Wednesday.

“We warn them against trying to play on their nerves, testing our patience," Ryabkov said, according to state-run news agency RIA Novosti.

Referring to the incident last week, he said the US drone "was in a zone where we introduced a special regime associated with conducting military exercises.”

Russia's security would be ensured “by all means available,” he added, and “no American drones, whether reconnaissance, strike, strategic or any other kind,” could “shake their determination.” 

Some background: CNN reported Tuesday that the US is flying surveillance drones further south above the Black Sea after a Russian jet collided with a US drone last week, citing two US officials.

The drone flights have remained in international airspace, but since the collision between one of the Russian jets and the MQ-9 Reaper drone last Tuesday, the US has moved its drone flights further away from airspace surrounding the Crimean peninsula and eastern portions of the Black Sea.

One of the officials said the routes are part of an effort “to avoid being too provocative,” as the Biden administration remains careful to avoid an incident that could potentially escalate into a direct conflict between US and Russian forces.

The official said the drone flights would continue this way “for the time being,” but added there is already “an appetite” to return to the routes closer to Russian-held territory. The officials also said Russia may try to unilaterally declare a broader closure of airspace around southern and eastern Ukraine in an attempt to force US drone flights further out. 

4:10 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Russian drone attacks kill 3 in Kyiv region

From CNN's Svitlana Vlasova in Kyiv

A view shows the building heavily damaged by a Russian drone strikes in the town of Rzhyshchiv, in Kyiv region on Wednesday.
A view shows the building heavily damaged by a Russian drone strikes in the town of Rzhyshchiv, in Kyiv region on Wednesday. (Head of the National Police of Kyiv Region, Andrii Nebytov/Telegram/Reuters)

Three people were killed in the Kyiv region overnight following a wave of Russian attacks with Iran-made Shahed drones, according to Ukrainian authorities.

Andrii Niebytov, the Kyiv region's police chief, said seven others were injured when a drone struck a dormitory building in the town of Rzhyshchiv.

Police and emergency services evacuated more than 200 people and more than 20 were taken to the hospital — but five people remain missing, Niebytov said.

Four people may be trapped under the rubble, Ukraine's State Emergency Service said.

A total of 21 drones were launched against Ukraine from the north shortly before midnight local time on Tuesday, 16 of which were shot down, according to the Ukrainian air force.

Serhiy Popko, head of the Kyiv military administration, said eight drones were shot down near the capital, where an air alert was in force for more than four hours.

In the Zhytomyr region to the west of Kyiv, three drones were shot down by Ukrainian air defenses, according to the local military administration.

3:24 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Russia-installed official says drone attack "thwarted" in Crimea

From CNN’s Josh Pennington 

A drone attack was “thwarted” in the Crimean port city of Sevastopol early on Wednesday, according to a local Russia-backed official.

“As of now, a total of three objects have been destroyed. They were trying to penetrate into the bay, and our navy men fired small arms on them. They also engaged the air defense system with one aerial drone,” Sevastopol Gov. Mikhail Razvozhaev said in a post on Telegram. 
“Our warships were not damaged. In the wake of the explosion caused by the destruction of the maritime drones, windows were blown out in buildings at Lenina 2 and a house on Moscow [street]. There were no casualties.”

CNN could not independently verify Razvozhaev’s claim.

Sevastopol is the largest city in the annexed Crimean peninsula and home to Russia's Black Sea fleet. Some of Russia’s most important warships have been docked there, including surface ships equipped with cruise missiles.

The US has previously accused Russia of using cruise missiles fired from ships in the Black Sea to hit civilian targets in Ukraine. 

Train strike: The report Tuesday comes after Ukraine’s Ministry of Defense said late Monday that a strike destroyed Russian “Kalibr” cruise missiles that were being transported by train in the Crimean town of Dzhankoi.

Ukrainian authorities did not directly claim responsibility for that strike but said it serves to further “demilitarize Russia and prepare the Crimean peninsula for de-occupation.”

3:33 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Japan pledges $30 million to Ukraine for non-lethal equipment, NHK reports

From CNN's Sandi Sidhu

Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida, left, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky hold a joint press conference after talks in Kyiv on Tuesday.
Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida, left, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky hold a joint press conference after talks in Kyiv on Tuesday. (Kyodo News/Getty Images)

Japan will provide $30 million to help Ukraine acquire non-lethal equipment, Prime Minister Fumio Kishida said, according to public broadcaster NHK.

Kishida made the announcement Tuesday at a joint news conference with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky during his surprise visit to Kyiv, NHK reported. 

"Japan will continue providing seamless support," to Ukraine "until peace returns to its beautiful land," Kishida was quoted as saying by NHK. 

Kishida's unexpected trip to Ukraine Tuesday was announced as Chinese leader Xi Jinping held talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow.

His visit was the first from a Japanese prime minister to a country or region with ongoing fighting since World War II, according to NHK. It was also the first visit to Ukraine by an Asian member of the G7 grouping and the first by a United States ally in the region.

The dual visits by Kishida and Xi underscore deep divisions in northeast Asia toward the war in Ukraine, with Japan pledging substantial aid for Kyiv, while China remains a lone voice supporting an increasingly isolated Putin — now a global pariah and suspected war criminal.

Kishida is scheduled to travel to Poland on Wednesday.

2:00 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Chinese leader Xi Jinping departs Russia 

From CNN's Beijing Bureau 

Chinese leader Xi Jinping has departed Russia and is heading back to China, according to Chinese state media outlet CCTV. 

"On March 22 morning local time, President Xi ends his state visit and departs from Russia back to China," CCTV reported.

It brings an end to a three-day state visit in which the Chinese leader and Russian President Vladimir Putin pledged to deepen ties in a show of unity that has heightened concerns Beijing will provide cover for the Kremlin's war in Ukraine.

5:50 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Analysis: How Xi and Putin's new friendship could test the US

Analysis from CNN's Stephen Collinson

Russian President Vladimir Putin meets with Chinese leader Xi Jinping at the Kremlin on Tuesday.
Russian President Vladimir Putin meets with Chinese leader Xi Jinping at the Kremlin on Tuesday. (Grigoy Sysoyev/Sputnik/AFP/Getty Images)

As two autocrats traded tributes over a feast of quail, venison, Siberian white salmon and pomegranate sorbet, China and Russia seemed to conjure the anti-Western compact the US has long feared.

Chinese leader Xi Jinping’s state visit this week to his friend, President Vladimir Putin, came at a critical moment of Russia’s quagmire war in Ukraine and of Beijing’s emergence as a great power whose influence now stretches far beyond Asia.

The entire visit has been refracted through a prism of both nations’ mutual antagonism toward the United States. And at every step, Washington, watching hawkishly from the sidelines, poured scorn on the idea of China as a peacemaker in Ukraine, accusing Xi of offering diplomatic cover to a thuggish Russian leader who was just cited for war crimes by the International Criminal Court.

But whether China and Russia have truly forged the kind of united anti-US front long dreaded by Washington’s foreign policy professionals seems doubtful.

Still, the United States clearly now has a serious foreign policy challenge on its hands. The US is simultaneously gearing up for what many experts warn could become a Cold War with China and waging a proxy fight in Ukraine with its foe in the 20th century’s version of that showdown. And China and Russia, together, have more capacity to frustrate American goals in Ukraine and elsewhere.

Xi and Putin are united on a core foreign policy priority — discrediting and even dismantling a world order that they believe is built on Western hypocrisy and denies them due respect as great global powers. This resentment has festered in Putin’s mind ever since the Soviet Union collapsed, and he has tried for years to reshape the international system. But according to Biden’s national security strategy, China is the only US competitor with “the economic, diplomatic, military, and technological power to” reshape that order.

Read the full analysis here.

12:07 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

Ukrainian troops impress US trainers as they rapidly get up to speed on Patriot missile system

From CNN's Natasha Bertrand and Aileen Graef in Fort Sill, Oklahoma

The Ukrainian soldiers waved and honked their horns as they drove along a dirt road at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, moving their vehicles into position to defend against a hypothetical Russian missile barrage.

These were not ordinary trucks, however. The Ukrainians were manning a US Patriot air defense system, which 65 Ukrainian soldiers have been training on intensively for 10 weeks, instructed by US Army trainers at the base.

CNN was invited to witness the training on Tuesday, just days ahead of the Ukrainians’ expected graduation from the expedited course. The training at Fort Sill is the only location on US soil where the US is instructing the Ukrainians on US weapons systems. But video and photographs of the training were prohibited, to protect the identities of the Ukrainians who will be heading home to defend their country against Russian forces within the next month.

The Ukrainians have excelled, officials said. They learned the basics of the Patriot system so quickly that they were given extra, intensive training rarely afforded to their American counterparts completing the same course, the officials added.

“Our assessment is that the Ukrainian soldiers are impressive, and absolutely a quick study due to their extensive air defense knowledge and experience in a combat zone,” said Brig. Gen. Shane Morgan, acting Fort Sill and Fires Center of Excellence commanding general.

Read more here.

12:10 a.m. ET, March 22, 2023

White House official says Russia-China relationship is built on mutual interest to challenge US

From CNN's Jennifer Z Deaton

John Kirby speaks to Christiane Amanpour in an interview with CNN.
John Kirby speaks to Christiane Amanpour in an interview with CNN. (CNN)

The deepening relationship between China and Russia was due in large part to their mutual interest in challenging the US' global influence, John Kirby, National Security Council spokesperson, told CNN's Christiane Amanpour Tuesday. 

“Where they intersect is pushing back on the United States and our influence around the world," Kirby said. "Where they intersect is pushing back on this thing we call the rules-based international order. Which I know sounds kind of like a wonky term, but it’s basically the rule of law and the foundational principles of the UN charter by which nations around the world are supposed to abide. And they’re pushing back against that."

Kirby's remarks come as Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin forge closer ties in Moscow in a show of unity that has heightened Western concerns that Beijing will provide cover for Russia's war in Ukraine.

"They’d like to change the rules of the game," Kirby said. "And in each other they see a useful foil. They see a useful friend. But that’s what they’re doing. They’re basically trying to use each other here to challenge US leadership and the West — particularly in Europe — but elsewhere around the world.”

In a joint statement released by China’s Foreign Ministry on Wednesday, Xi and Putin said their partnership is in the “fundamental interests” of both countries, adding that “Russia needs a prosperous and stable China, and China needs a strong and successful Russia.”