Live updates: Trump impeachment inquiry | CNN Politics

The latest on the Trump impeachment inquiry

In this January 2016 file photo, U.S. Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump shows a sheet with poll numbers as he speaks at a rally at Iowa State University in Ames, Iowa.
Trump says he wants to read Ukraine call in 'fireside chat'
2:04 • Source: CNN
In this January 2016 file photo, U.S. Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump shows a sheet with poll numbers as he speaks at a rally at Iowa State University in Ames, Iowa.
2:04

Where things stand now

  • The latest: The House approved a resolution yesterday formalizing the procedures of the impeachment inquiry into President Trump. Rep. Adam Schiff said some of the transcripts of the closed-door interviews could be made public as early as next week.
  • Subpoenas issued: The House Intelligence Committee issued subpoenas to John Eisenberg, the top lawyer on the White House’s National Security Council, and Brian McCormack, the former chief of staff to Energy Secretary Rick Perry, according to a source familiar with the matter.
  • Possible timeline: Democrats are discussing a time frame that would include public impeachment hearings before Thanksgiving and votes on whether to impeach Trump by Christmas, multiple Democratic sources have told CNN.
  • Sign up for CNN’s Impeachment Watch newsletter here.
36 Posts

Our live coverage has ended, but you can scroll through the posts below to read the latest updates.

Trump gives animated defense of his Ukraine phone call

President Trump delivers remarks during a campaign rally in Tupelo, Mississippi, on Nov. 1.

President Trump went on a tear at his first rally since the House voted on a path forward for an impeachment inquiry.

The President, speaking to a crowd at a “Keep America Great” rally in Tupelo, Mississippi, did not hold back when it came to attacking the inquiry.

Trump called the proceedings a “deranged witch hunt” and an “attack on democracy itself.” He extensively defended his phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky that set off the inquiry.

“They’re so damn dishonest,” the President told the crowd of supporters, “and they’ll just say let’s use Ukraine for help. And they won’t show the laughter and they won’t show the sarcasm and they won’t show the fun. Because they’re the most dishonorable people almost on earth.”

He claimed he didn’t even know Zelensky’s name when he called the leader.

“I don’t know who he is. I didn’t know his name until I looked down at the card,” he said.

He continued, saying he’s, “an honest person anyway, but do you think when I’m making a call to a newly elected president of a country, do you think I would say something improper when I knew there were all these people on the line?”

The President went on to detail all the people who could have been on the line.

“Whoever the hell wants to listen, they’ll listen, and they have me making some kind of a deal with all these people,” Trump said. “These people are sick.”

 Trump also laid out several conspiracy theories about the investigations. “The Democrats, the media and the deep state are desperate to stop us. And it’s not me it’s us, it’s all of is,” he told crowd.

Trump exaggerates accomplishments on unemployment

President Trump can accurately boast about the unemployment rate, 3.6% in September.

That remains the lowest in just under 50 years, if you don’t count earlier months in the Trump presidency.

Instead, Trump said it was the lowest in “over 51 years.”

As we’ve written before, he is endlessly exaggerating accomplishments that are impressive even if cited correctly. 

Trump falsely claims that Michelle Obama campaigned for Stacey Abrams

Former first lady Michelle Obama

President Trump invoked former President Barack Obama multiple times at the rally, referring to him on occasion as “Barack Hussein Obama.”

He claimed that Republican Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp had defeated Democratic candidate Stacey Abrams, even though Abrams had not only Barack Obama but former first lady Michelle Obama campaigning for her. Michelle Obama never campaigned for Abrams.

During tonight’s rally, Trump also criticized CNN at length. And as he has repeatedly before, he claimed that he had just seen that CNN turned off its camera as he was doing this criticism, not wanting to televise such comments.

CNN did not turn off its camera.

Trump complains about not receiving sufficient coverage over ISIS leader's death

President Trump complained that he is not receiving sufficient coverage over the death of ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.

He alleged that a Democrat would get more credit.

And Trump added: “With me, they don’t even wanna — they actually played it down. And actually, and I’m happy about this — Conan, the dog, got more publicity than me. And I’m very happy about that.”

About the ISIS leader: Baghdadi “blew himself up” after he was cornered by US forces during a daring, two-hour nighttime raid on his compound in northern Syria on Saturday.

Trump says he's "an honest guy." But a CNN count found he made 96 false claims just last week.

President Trump arrives to deliver remarks at a Keep America Great campaign rally in Tupelo, Mississippi, on Nov. 1.

President Trump has been serially dishonest — making 96 false claims just last week, by CNN’s count, and more than 1,000 since we started counting each one on July 8.

At tonight’s rally, though, Trump said, “I’m an honest guy.”

Speaking of Democrats, he decried “the lying” and “the falsifying.”

He added: “Remember this: truth is a force of nature.”

NSC official tried to find out if ambassador went rogue or acted at Trump's direction on Ukraine

Tim Morrison arrives for a deposition at the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on Oct. 31.

A top White House official told lawmakers he tried to find out whether President Trump told a key US diplomat he wanted Ukraine to investigate the Bidens, multiple sources familiar with his closed-door deposition on Capitol Hill told CNN.

His actions show concern inside the White House about the extent of the President’s role in the push for investigations that could help Trump politically.

Tim Morrison, the top Russia and Europe adviser on Trump’s National Security Council, had multiple conversations with American Ambassador to the European Union Gordon Sondland. In those discussions, the ambassador referenced talks he had with the President. Morrison became concerned that Sondland was going rogue on Ukraine.

Morrison told lawmakers he thought Sondland was a “free radical,” according to two of the sources. The term was a reference to cells that cause cancer.

To find out whether Sondland had talked to the President, Morrison went so far as asking Trump’s executive secretary if the President had actually talked with Sondland. The ambassador’s claims about the conversations checked out each time, Morrison said in his testimony Thursday, according to the sources.

In his own opening statement, Sondland downplayed both Trump’s role and his own in the effort to pressure Ukraine— suggesting he was reluctantly working with Rudy Giuliani, the President’s personal attorney, who was running a shadow diplomatic operation in Ukraine.

Keep reading here.

Republicans demand Pelosi release unredacted impeachment transcripts to all House members 

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi

House Republicans are sending letters of protest to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi arguing that unredacted transcripts from closed depositions and hearings in the impeachment inquiry against President Trump must be made available to all House members.

In the letter, they say, “To the extent that you make any redactions in any of the transcripts, all members of the House must be supplied copies of the full and unredacted transcripts,” arguing that House rules demand nothing less. 

House Republicans argue that Pelosi’s “duty to the Constitution and the American people, as well as fundamental fairness, requires that you immediately release the full transcripts of all depositions taken since you pronounced the beginning of an impeachment inquiry on September 24, 2019.” 

Republicans accuse Democrats of selectively leaking testimony from witnesses to help their case.

“The selective leaking in which the House Intelligence Committee has been engaged must end immediately and the full and complete record must be provided for the American people to see,” they wrote.

House Intelligence Chairman Adam Schiff told CNN’s Chris Cuomo on “Cuomo Prime Time” Thursday night that he plans to release transcripts from the closed-door hearings as early as next week. 

“Those arguments you’ve heard are almost completely false, with only one exception,” Schiff said. “And when you see the transcripts, and we expect to begin releasing them as early as next week, you’ll see that the Republicans have every bit as much time to ask questions.”

Trump holds campaign rally in Mississippi tonight

President Trump talks to reporters before departing the White House on Nov. 1 in Washington, DC.

President Trump is holding a rally tonight in Tupelo, Mississippi, a day after the House approved a resolution to formalize the procedures of the impeachment inquiry.

Earlier today, Trump’s campaign said the vote has only emboldened the President’s supporters and bolstered their campaign contributions.

According to Parscale, the campaign raised $3 million online in one day, totaling $19 million in funds raised over the course of the month. The $3 million addition came the same day the House passed the resolution, which the campaign called a “sham.”

You can watch the rally live in the video player above or here.

House Intelligence Committee issues subpoenas to two impeachment witnesses

The House Intelligence Committee issued subpoenas to John Eisenberg, the top lawyer on the White House’s National Security Council, and Brian McCormack, the former chief of staff to Energy Secretary Rick Perry, according to a source familiar with the matter.

Both are scheduled to appear Monday for a closed-door deposition. It’s still unclear whether they will appear.

A spokesperson for the House Intelligence Committee declined to comment. 

House Democrats ask Energy Secretary Rick Perry to testify in impeachment inquiry

House impeachment investigators have asked Energy Secretary Rick Perry to testify in the probe into President Trump, an official working on the impeachment inquiry told CNN.

Perry is scheduled to testify on Wednesday.

Department of Energy spokesperson Shaylyn Hynes said Perry will not participate in the closed-door deposition.

“The secretary will not partake in a secret star chamber inquisition where agency counsel is forbidden to be present,” Hynes said. “If the committee is interested in conducting a serious proceeding they are welcome to send for the secretary’s consideration an invitation to participate in an open hearing where the Department’s counsel can be present and the American people can witness.”

Here’s who else is scheduled to testify in closed sessions that day:

  • Russell Vought, acting director of the Office of Management and Budget
  • David Hale, the Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs
  • State Department Counselor Ulrich Brechbuhl

It is unclear if any or all of these witnesses will show up to the sessions. 

The official said the House committees are in ongoing discussions with other witnesses.

Podcast: Trump moves one giant step closer to impeachment — but has a pretty good day

In the latest episode of “The Daily DC: Impeachment Watch” podcast, CNN’s Vicky Ward covers: 

  • Tim Morrison’s testimony and what both sides are saying about it
  • Why the GOP has continued to stand behind President Trump
  • The political and electoral consequences for Democrats following yesterday’s impeachment resolution
  • The new public phase of the impeachment inquiry
  • Whether yesterday’s court proceedings involving two impeachment witnesses will impact the inquiry timeline

Ward is joined today by “SE Cupp Unfiltered” host S.E. Cupp and CNN legal analyst Jennifer Rodgers.

Listen to the podcast here.

2 GOP lawmakers quietly offer guidance to White House lawyers

Reps. Jim Jordan (L) and Mark Meadows (R) speak to reporters on Oct. 31 in Washington, DC.

As House Democrats build their case for impeaching President Trump through a succession of closed-door depositions, a pair of Trump’s closest allies on Capitol Hill are quietly offering guidance to the White House lawyers responsible for crafting the President’s defense strategy.

Reps. Mark Meadows and Jim Jordan, members of the conservative House Freedom Caucus who have attended the depositions, have been informally helping attorneys in the White House Counsel’s office sort through publicly reported aspects of the testimony to the extent they can, according to four administration officials.

The conversations are primarily aimed at helping White House lawyers get a better grasp of the allegations being leveled at Trump and potential weak points as the White House begins to craft a legal strategy to defend Trump during his impeachment trial, two administration officials said.

White House lawyers have not been permitted to attend the closed-door depositions – a top GOP complaint about the impeachment inquiry – and people familiar with the matter said the conversations are aimed at helping the White House gauge the seriousness of leaked allegations from the testimony that have painted a damning picture of the President’s conduct.

The White House did not respond to a request for comment.

Meadows said he has only shared “broad characterizations” and is “not sharing specifics” of the testimony with the White House, pointing to House rules preventing him from disclosing details of the testimony, which are held in secure rooms called Sensitive Compartmented Information Facilities, or SCIFs. When some witnesses — such as US ambassador to the European Union Gordon Sondland — have backed up aspects of the President’s defense of his conduct, he has pointed that out.

White House Ukraine expert was told not to talk about Trump-Zelensky call

Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman

Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman, the National Security Council’s top Ukraine expert, testified this week that he was told not to talk with anyone about the July 25 call between President Trump and the Ukrainian president, according to a source familiar with the testimony.

Vindman testified that he was concerned about the July call between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, and he took those concerns to National Security Council lawyer John Eisenberg, who told him not to discuss the call, the source said.

Eisenberg and NSC lawyers moved the transcript of the call onto a higher security system than what’s typically used for presidential calls — a decision that’s among the issues Democratic impeachment investigators are probing.

Politico first reported that Eisenberg told Vindman not to discuss the call.

Vindman told lawmakers that while he was concerned about the call, he testified the rough transcript released by the White House was mostly accurate, but he proposed two edits to include a reference to Burisma and Vice President Joe Biden’s tapes that were not included. 

Tim Morrison, another NSC official on the July call, testified Thursday that his concern was over the call leaking, but he did not think there was anything wrong with Trump’s call. Sources told CNN Thursday Morrison was involved with discussions to move the call to the more secure system.

These are the witnesses asked to testify next week

Six witnesses are currently scheduled to testify in the ongoing House impeachment investigation on Monday and Tuesday of next week.

It is still unclear if any of the witnesses on Monday will actually be testifying. 

The following witnesses are expected to testify in closed-door sessions on Monday:

  • John Eisenberg, the top lawyer on the White House’s National Security Council
  • Robert Blair, a White House aide who is a senior adviser to acting White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney
  • Michael Ellis, the No. 2 lawyer on the White House’s National Security Council
  • Brian McCormack, a senior official at the Office of Management and Budget

The following witnesses are expected to testify on Tuesday:

  • Wells Griffith, special assistant to the President and senior director for international energy and environment at National Security Council
  • Michael Duffey, associate director for national security programs at the Office of Management and Budget

Some context: Eisenberg, alongside former national security adviser John Bolton, has emerged as a key figure in the testimony provided by administration officials so far detailing President Trump’s approach to Ukraine.

The top national security lawyer at the White House, Eisenberg was approached by several officials — including Russia director Fiona Hill and the top Ukraine expert Alexander Vindman — with concerns about apparent attempts to coerce Ukraine’s new president into opening investigations into Trump’s political rivals.

Eisenberg was responsible for the decision to place the rough transcript of Trump’s phone call with Ukraine’s president in a highly secure server. And he was among those inside the White House who first learned a whistleblower had filed a complaint about the Ukraine matter.

Kellyanne Conway: It's "certainly possible" Trump will be impeached

White House counselor Kellyanne Conway said it was “certainly possible” that President Trump would ultimately be impeached by the House.

She reiterated that Trump is in charge of his own defense against an impeachment inquiry in the House of Representatives. 

“We have many people working on that,” Conway said, “but we have overstuffed portfolios here to begin with working on the business of America which does not include impeachment.”

She added that she assumed that it would be a “press and comms,” the “legal team” and “other people involved.” 

“But the President has been quite transparent in his daily explanation of what he thinks of the entire process and substance,” Conway said.

She went on to accuse Democrats of “lying to their constituents.” 

“They said they were coming here to reduce drug prices and get some infrastructure going, and help in Syria, but they’re not,” she said. “They’re trying to investigate and impeach the President. They’ll need to go home and answer for that.”

6 things happening today in the impeachment inquiry

Congress is in recess, but the impeachment inquiry into President Trump continues.

Here’s what’s happening today:

  • New polls: Two new polls show Americans are divided on the impeachment inquiry. A poll from the University of Texas and the Texas Tribune found that Texas voters were about evenly split over whether Trump should be removed from office before the end of his term. The Washington Post/ABC News poll shows Americans are split along party lines on whether to impeach and remove Trump.
  • White House goes on defense: White House press secretary Stephanie Grisham called the ongoing impeachment inquiry “a sham and a kangaroo court” in an interview with Fox News this morning. She said Democrats were “unhinged” and described the ongoing probe “unjust and unfair.”
  • Meanwhile: Brad Parscale, Trump’s campaign manager, said the campaign raised $3 million online in just one day following the House’s vote formalizing impeachment procedures yesterday.
  • House on recess: Rep. Adam Schiff, the chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, told CNN the House recess, which will go through Nov. 11, will not impede their investigation. Schiff said some of the transcripts of the closed-door interviews could be made public as early as next week. 
  • New video emerges: News footage from an Oct. 20, 2018, midterm election rally in Nevada shows indicted Rudy Giuliani associate Lev Parnas standing behind President Trump. In the videos, Parnas sits in the area directly behind Trump before and during the rally. Parnas and his business partner and fellow Giuliani associate, Igor Fruman, are alleged by prosecutors to have illegally funded donations from foreign nations to Republican political campaigns in attempts to buy influence.
  • About that “fireside chat”: In an interview with the Washington Examiner, Trump threw out the idea of hosting a “fireside chat” to read the transcript of his July 25 call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. The call is at the center of the impeachment investigation.

Elizabeth Warren on a possible Senate impeachment trial: "I'll be there"

Sen. Elizabeth Warren, one of the frontrunners in the Democratic presidential nomination, was asked on the campaign trail if impeachment moves to a trial in Senate how her campaign will adapt. Warren responded, “I’ll be there.”

Warren has called for President Trump’s impeachment. She said today that he “clearly broke the law with Ukraine.”

“This man has made clear that if he is given the chance, he will do anything — including break the law — to try to save his own skin,” Warren said about Trump. “That’s why it’s time for accountability, and the tool in the Constitution of the United States for accountability is impeachment.”

Reminder: A trial in Senate will only happen if the House first votes to impeach Trump. If that happens, sitting senators — like Warren — would serve as jurors in an impeachment trial.

What we know about the House impeachment resolution

The House passed a resolution formalizing procedures of the impeachment inquiry into President Trump yesterday.

About the vote: It was not a vote to impeach Trump — rather, it was a vote to formalize the impeachment proceedings. A vote to impeach Trump would happen after the House Judiciary Committee votes on the articles of impeachment. The House is still conducting its investigation.

What we know about the timing:  House Democrats are discussing a time frame that would include public impeachment hearings before Thanksgiving, multiple Democratic sources have told CNN, though the timing remains fluid.

Rep. Jerry Nadler, the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, told CNN earlier this week that it’s “possible” a vote could be held in his committee on articles of impeachment before Christmas.

If the articles are approved, they are given special status on the House floor. It requires a simple majority of voting lawmakers to approve them. This full House vote would be the vote to impeach the President.

Remember: The impeachment process can take months. Only three US presidents have faced impeachment. They are…

  • For Andrew Johnson, the entire process lasted 94 days, from first congressional action to Senate acquittal, lasted from February 22, 1868 to May 26, 1868.
  • For Richard Nixon, it lasted 184 days. The House approved the impeachment inquiry on February 6, 1974 and Nixon announced he’d resign on August 8, 1974.
  • For Bill Clinton, it lasted 127 days. The House approved the impeachment inquiry on October 8, 1998, and the Senate acquitted him on February 12, 1999.

You can read more about the impeachment process here.

Pelosi on Republicans not supporting the impeachment inquiry: "That's their problem"

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi gavels the close of a vote by the U.S. House of Representatives on a resolution formalizing the impeachment inquiry into President Trump

In an interview with Bloomberg TV today, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi was asked if the impeachment inquiry will remain focused on the Ukraine matter, or if it will expand beyond that to other questions about President Trump’s behavior. She said it will be up to the committees of jurisdiction.

“There were 11 obstruction of justice provisions in the Mueller report,” she added later. “Perhaps some of them will be part of this, but again that will be part of the inquiry to see where we go.”

She also hit Republicans for not supporting the probe.

GO DEEPER

GO DEEPER

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app on Google Play.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from Google Play.

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.