CNN town hall in South Carolina: Live updates from Biden, Bloomberg, Klobuchar and Warren | CNN Politics

CNN town hall with Biden, Bloomberg, Klobuchar and Warren

07 cnn town hall 0226 klobuchar
Klobuchar explains how she would combat sexism
2:21 • Source: CNN
07 cnn town hall 0226 klobuchar
2:21

What we covered here

  • Democratic presidential candidates Michael Bloomberg, Joe Biden, Amy Klobuchar and Elizabeth Warren answered questions from voters in back-to-back town halls.
40 Posts

4 key takeaways from tonight's CNN town halls

Four Democratic presidential candidates answered a host of questions at back-to-back town halls in South Carolina.

We’re wrapping up our live coverage. In case you missed it, here’s the key takeaway from each candidate’s town hall:

  • Michael Bloomberg: The billionaire businessman was called to task once again over his controversial record on stop-and-frisk, which he repeatedly defended while serving as mayor of New York. Bloomberg said tonight, “we just did it much too much and an awful lot of innocent people got stopped.” Stop-and-frisk searches peaked under Bloomberg at 203,500 stops during the first three months of 2012.The practice was cut back amid protests and lawsuits.
  • Joe Biden: The former vice president said he has spoken to Anita Hill, who made sexual harassment accusations against Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, and “apologized for not being able to protect her more” during Thomas’ confirmation hearings, which Biden oversaw in 1991. Biden was asked what would happen if President Trump loses in November but refuses to concede. Biden said the way Trump has treated the military, the intelligence community and the FBI, “I have no worry about him being escorted out of the White House.” 
  • Amy Klobuchar: Klobuchar vowed to fire Education Secretary Betsy DeVos in her “first 100 seconds” if elected president. The Minnesota senator also said she would be able to work with progressive Democrats like Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, if elected, and pointed out that they already do in the Senate.
  • Elizabeth Warren: The Massachusetts senator is ready for a convention floor battle this summer if none of the Democratic candidates reach a delegate majority during the primary. Warren made it clear tonight that she’d be willing to lobby superdelegates, who have a vote on the second ballot if there’s no outright winner, when asked if she would continue her candidacy even if she was trailing in the delegate count. She also tackled the issue of coronavirus, pledging to divert funds from President Trump’s border wall and use “every dime” of it to fight the escalating health threat.

Warren won't say if Massachusetts primary is a "must-win"

Elizabeth Warren isn’t saying if her home state of Massachusetts is a “must-win” on Super Tuesday.

“I’m grateful for those folks” and their support, Warren said when asked. “Always grateful.”

But on Wednesday night, like she has in the past, Warren didn’t give a clear answer as to whether she believes victory in the Bay State is a requirement for her campaign on March 3.  

Watch:

Warren says she won’t let Trump "get behind me on a debate stage"

Elizabeth Warren said Wednesday that the best way to take on Donald Trump is to stand up to him because “you never back down from a bully.”

The comment came in response to a question about the way Trump gives his opponents nicknames, including an offensive name used for Warren.

“So, do remember whoever the nominee is Donald Trump will have ugly names, tell lies, and make it his personal and nasty as he can,” Warren said. “So, we’re just there. That’s what’s going to happen.”

But, Warren said, that Democrats cannot be consumed by fighting with Trump.

“The way we’ll beat Donald Trump is by making this election not just about Donald Trump,” Warren said. “I think the way we’ll do it is by talking about our vision.”

Watch the moment:

Warren uses affordable hearing aids as an example of how she can work with Republicans

When it comes to working with Republican on passing legislation, Sen. Elizabeth Warren cited a bill she authored aimed at the 40 million Americans who suffer from hearing loss.

Warren cited how “one out of every six actually gets a hearing aid. Why? Because a couple of hearing aids cost you in the neighborhood of $5,000, not covered by insurance, not covered by medicare for most people. They just can’t afford it.”

Warren’s plan was simple: Sell hearing aids over the counter. That plan is now a reality.

President Trump signed Warren’s Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Act of 2017, which aims to make hearing aids more affordable and had bipartisan support. It requires the Food and Drug Administration to allow certain hearing aids to be sold over-the-counter to Americans with mild to moderate hearing loss.

“This law will make a life changing difference for millions of Americans who experience hearing loss but can’t access the hearing aid technology they need because of high costs and excessive regulations,” Warren said in a statement at the time of the President’s signing.

Hear more:

Warren believes corruption is at the heart of cigarette addiction in the US

Sen. Elizabeth Warren wants to snuff out cigarette addiction in the US and tackle an industry rife with “corruption.”

Warren’s discussion on cigarettes was prompted by a question from Tracy Smith, a professor in addiction sciences, who said “cigarette smoking still kills 50% of long term users and still the leading cause preventable death in the United States. And worldwide.”

“What will you do as president to help end cigarette addiction and the disease burden of tobacco in the country,” Smith asked.

Warren’s answer focused on a “tobacco industry that still calling the shots too often in Washington. And that leans on the FDA to stay out of doing science based, health based regulations,” she said tonight during her town hall.

Watch the moment:

Warren once compared the 2020 race to a movie. Here's why.

Elizabeth Warren once compared the race for the presidency to a movie. She said it was lonely.

Here’s why:

She then detailed something that makes her campaign unique: A selfie line.

Warren described the stories of hardship she’s heard from Americans across the country during her selfie lines. She went on to say “the reason I say that’s lonely, every one of those, it’s like it comes in between your ribs.”

Her campaign and the race to the White House is a culmination of her “life’s work,” she said.

Hear her comments:

Warren: I'm ready for a convention floor fight

Elizabeth Warren is ready for a convention floor battle this summer if none of the Democratic candidates reach a delegate majority during the primary.

Warren made it clear on Wednesday night that she’d be willing to lobby superdelegates, who have a vote on the second ballot if there’s no outright winner, when asked if she would continue her candidacy even if she was trailing in the delegate count.

Asked by an audience member why the person who gets the most votes shouldn’t be awarded the nomination, Warren said that the rules set a higher bar — and she intended fight to the last.

Warren also suggested that Bernie Sanders’ argument that a candidate with a plurality should be declared the nominee was disingenuous, noting that his 2016 campaign, despite losing to Hillary Clinton, publicly argued that convention superdelegates should consider swinging the contest in his favor.

In the aftermath of that primary, in which the superdelegates overwhelmingly backed Clinton, Sanders and others struck a deal to dilute their power. Unlike four years ago, they will only be able to vote on a second ballot in 2020.

But in this crowded field, that compromise could come back to bite Sanders.

“When they were putting together the 2016 platform for the Democratic convention, those are the rules he wanted to write. And others wanted to write. Everybody got in the race thinking that was the set of rules,” she added. “I don’t see how come you get to change it because he thinks that an advantage to him for doing it.”

Watch:

Housing is a big part of how Warren wants to help at-risk communities

Dana Lang, an attorney, has a son with autism who is about to graduate from high school and eager to become independent.

During Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s town hall tonight, Lang asked the Massachusetts lawmaker what plan she has for “integrating this generation of young adults with autism who are ageing out of school system” and what can she do to ensure people like him have “meaningful lives in the community?”

Warren cited her background as a special education teacher and how housing remains at the crux of her plan for helping people like Lang’s son.

Warren went on to explain how the US is in need of 3.2 million new housing units to help “middle class families, for working class families, housing for the working poor. Housing for the poor poor. Housing for homeless. For people with disabilities. Housing for seniors who want to age in place. For people who have been incarcerated and making it back into the community.”

Warren added: “We need to treat housing like a basic human right. And safe accessible housing for everyone.”

See the moment:

Warren says she wants go after gun dealers to address gun violence

Elizabeth Warren outlined tonight the first executive order she would sign to address gun violence.

She vowed that her first action would be to go after gun dealers.

“We have let so many loopholes slip through. It turns out that most of the data suggest it’s a handful of dealers and people who show up at gun shows who are getting most of the guns into circulation,” Warren said.

The Massachusetts senator went on to say she wants to address gun violence as if it were a “public health emergency.”

“That’s what I want to see us do on guns. I want to see us do the things that are obvious the background checks. Get assault weapons off our streets,” she said.

Hear Sen. Warren’s response:

Warren: I'll use border wall money to combat coronavirus

Elizabeth Warren on Wednesday pledged to divert funds from President Trump’s border wall and use “every dime” of it to fight the escalating threat of coronavirus.

She also criticized the administration’s announcement that Vice President Mike Pence would lead the current effort to combat the spread of the illness, saying his past performance in dealing with a health crisis had “disqualified” him from the job.

“Do keep in mind that this Vice President has dealt with a public health emergency before — in Indiana. And what was his approach? To put politics over science and let a serious virus expand in his state and cost people lives,” she said.

During his time as governor, Pence hesitated in green-lighting a needle exchange program designed to stop the spread of HIV in a rural Indiana county. Under his watch, the outbreak spread and at least 200 people were infected. 

See her response:

Warren vows to bring white supremacists "to justice"

Sen. Elizabeth Warren was emphatic in her denouncement of domestic terrorism following a question from the pastor of Charleston’s Mother Emanuel AME Church, where, in 2015, a white supremacist killed nine African-Americans during Bible study.

Rev. Eric Manning asked the Massachusetts senator during her town hall tonight what her response would be “to the families to the survivors of those who suffer at the hands of so much hatred and evil. And racism.”

Warren added: “That we commit as a people as a government that we will aggressively pursue white supremacists and that we will bring them to justice. I also believe that we have to redouble or efforts on gun violence. And as you know more than anyone, gun violence is an issue of mass shootings.”

Watch:

Elizabeth Warren's town hall has now started

Sen. Elizabeth Warren just took the stage at her CNN town hall in South Carolina, just days before the state’s primary and Super Tuesday.

Klobuchar: I can work with Sanders and Warren despite differences

Amy Klobuchar has a message for Democrats worried about the party’s progressive-moderate divide.

Chill.

Asked how, if elected, she could work with Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, Klobuchar pointed out that they already do in the Senate.

“I’ll bet you wish you were in those meetings and we have worked together on many, many issues and I admire both of them,” she said.

“I have worked with Elizabeth on a lot of the financial reforms and have supported the work that she has done there,” Klobuchar said. “I have worked with Bernie extensively on pharmaceutical issues … in bringing in less expensive drugs from other countries to bring the prices down.”

But the Minnesota senator did draw a line, noting that she opposed “Medicare for All.”

“I think it’s better to build on the Affordable Care Act with a public option,” Klobuchar said, referring to her own health care plan.

Watch:

One of the first things Klobuchar would do as president is fire Education Secretary Betsy DeVos

Tammie Green is an attorney and public defender who filed for bankruptcy after taking out public and private loans to pay for law school.

Green, who “is drowning in student loan debt,” asked Sen. Amy Klobuchar tonight during her town hall what help she would provide as president to her and many in her situation.

One of the things Klobuchar discussed was the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program and how it is “messed up.”

The repayment program allows borrowers who work in the public sector, like teachers and social workers to apply for debt cancellation after making 10 years’ worth of payments, was signed into law by President George W. Bush in 2007. But the first time anyone would have made enough payments to qualify was the fall of 2017, under the Trump administration.

Congress set aside $700 million to expand the program in 2018 to address the low number of people qualifying for forgiveness, but the new report shows that fix hasn’t had the desired results.

More on DeVos: DeVos and the Department of Education were held in civil contempt by a federal judge in late October and ordered to pay damages to student borrowers who took out loans to attend a now defunct for-profit college.

The judge had previously ordered the Department of Education to stop collecting on the loans. In September, the department admitted that more than 16,000 borrowers were incorrectly informed that they owed a payment on their debt after the court order. About 1,800 had their wages garnished and more than 800 were mistakenly subject to adverse credit reporting.

Under DeVos, the Department of Education has scrapped a rule that was intended to protect students from for-profit colleges, and is rewriting a rule about how defrauded students can qualify for loan forgiveness. DeVos and the department have also been sued over the high rejection rate in a debt forgiveness program for public sector workers.

Watch her comments:

Klobuchar explains what she was thinking in debate moment captured in photo

Amy Klobuchar explained tonight what she was thinking in a photo showing her in the middle of a heated debate between Joe Biden and Tom Steyer.

The moment happened on stage at the Democratic debate in South Carolina on Tuesday.

Here’s how she explained the moment:

Klobuchar went on to describe the debate as a “slug fest.”

Watch:

Klobuchar won’t say if Minnesota’s primary is a must-win for her campaign to continue

Amy Klobuchar, whose home state of Minnesota votes next week on Super Tuesday, wouldn’t say whether she would drop out of the Democratic presidential race if she loses there. 

She pointed to polls that show her narrowly ahead there. 

“The key part is not necessarily the primary. The key part is the general election,” she said, pointing to President Donald Trump’s frequent visits to Minnesota, a state Hillary Clinton narrowly won in 2016. 

See the moment:

Klobuchar defines Midwest as "states that feel that they've been left behind some" — including South Carolina

Amy Klobuchar, pressed on why she focuses so intently on reaching out to Midwestern voters, said she actually defines the Midwest as “the states that feel that they’ve been left behind some in terms of focus in the 2016 election.”

Klobuchar said she “would include states like South Carolina” in that description.

“Do you worry that this messaging isolates voters in other parts of the country such as south Carolina,” asked a voter. “How do you appeal to non-Midwest voters? 

“I really think about the Midwest and the states that feel that they’ve been left behind some in terms of focus in the 2016 election where we weren’t able to turn out our vote the way that we should,” Klobuchar said.

Klobuchar regularly touts connections to the Midwest, arguing her “grit” and “determination” come from her upbringing in Minnesota.

Watch:

Here's why Klobuchar thinks she is the better choice for black voters in South Carolina

When it comes to black voters in South Carolina, Sen. Amy Klobuchar believes she is the better choice for president when compared to former Vice President Joe Biden.

Klobuchar cited support she has received in her home state of Minnesota.

Klobuchar added: “I think there have been so many broken promises to the African-American community, and I’m not that person. I think some of my colleagues, I’m not referring to the vice president here, but some of my colleagues up on that debate stage were promising a lot of things that I don’t think they can deliver. I don’t want to be that person.”

Why this matters: The former vice president made no secret of his need for a big win Saturday to keep his presidential aspirations afloat.

During his town hall earlier tonight, Biden addressed South Carolina’s kingmaker status when it comes to the White House.

“You pick presidents, the Democratic primary here in this state, picks presidents,” Biden said tonight. “You’re the reason why Bill Clinton was elected president. You’re the reason Barack Obama was elected president. You represent the diversity of the population. Going into Super Tuesday, look, no Democrat has ever won the presidency without overwhelming support from number one, the African-American community, the most loyal support that exists in the Democratic party, and I do not take it for granted.”

Hear her response:

What Klobuchar plans to do to combat coronavirus

Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar laid out her plan tonight to combat the spread of coronavirus in the US if she’s elected president.

The Democratic senator said she would ensure the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is strong and that the US had “adequate medical help and research.”

Klobuchar went on to say she would invest in education “because the next vaccine or the next cure or the next way that we reduce the risk is probably right now in a college student at your college.”

Watch:

Klobuchar on Pence leading coronavirus response: "You might put a medical professional in charge"

Amy Klobuchar took issue with the fact that President Trump tapped Vice President Mike Pence to lead his administration’s response to the coronavirus on Wednesday.

Trump, during a briefing on Wednesday afternoon, announced that Pence would lead the government’s response to coronavirus as criticism of the White House’s handling of the outbreak has grown.

There have been more than 80,000 cases of coronavirus globally and the death toll has risen to more than 2,700, the majority in mainland China. The US has 60 confirmed cases, US health officials said Tuesday, a number that is expected to grow.

Klobuchar also said she believes Congress has a role in the coronavirus response.

“I think we want to make sure that everything is done in the right way and that’s the job of Congress to perform oversight,” she said

Hear Sen. Klobuchar’s response:

GO DEEPER

GO DEEPER

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app on Google Play.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from Google Play.

Download the CNN app

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.

Scan the QR code to download the CNN app from the Apple Store.