Why Trump Isn’t Taking New Hampshire for Granite - CNN One Thing - Podcast on CNN Audio

CNN

CNN Audio

9 AM ET: Protesters clash, Blinken on Gaza crisis, millions could lose internet & more
5 Things
Listen to
CNN 5 Things
Mon, Apr 29
New Episodes
How To Listen
On your computer On your mobile device Smart speakers
Explore CNN
US World Politics Business
podcast

CNN One Thing

You’ve been overwhelmed with headlines all week – what's worth a closer look? One Thing takes you into the story and helps you make sense of the news everyone's been talking about. Each Sunday, host David Rind interviews one of CNN’s world-class reporters to tell us what they've found – and why it matters. From the team behind CNN 5 Things.

Back to episodes list

Why Trump Isn’t Taking New Hampshire for Granite
CNN One Thing
Jan 21, 2024

After former President Donald Trump’s resounding win in Iowa, the Republican primary shifts to New Hampshire. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley are banking on undeclared voters to swing their way as Trump sharpens his attacks against the only two candidates left in the race. In this episode, we hear how those independents could change the dynamic of the race and why President Joe Biden’s campaign is quietly concerned about the Democratic primary in the state. 

Guest: Kasie Hunt, CNN Chief National Affairs Analyst 

Episode Transcript
David Rind
00:00:00
Last week on the show, we heard from a group of Iowa Republicans who told my colleague John King that they were pretty much ready to move on from former President Donald Trump.
Betsy Sarcone
00:00:10
I can't put my rubber stamp on Trump having more influence over this country.
Shanen Ebersole
00:00:16
I love what he did for small businesses. I love what he did for agriculture. I wish he could have done it a little bit quieter.
David Rind
00:00:26
Well, at the Iowa caucuses, Trump dashed those plans pretty much immediately.
Jake Tapper
00:00:31
CNN projects that Donald Trump will win the Iowa caucuses. CNN can make this projection based on his overwhelming lead in our entrance poll of Iowa caucus goers and some initial votes.
David Rind
00:00:43
'That are coming. CNN and other networks made that call before some precincts had even started voting. Trump won 98 of Iowa's 99 counties. Like this was a trouncing. So, like the great journalist John is, he followed up with these voters and the text messages they sent back were revealing, for example, on a possible rematch between Trump and President Joe Biden. Betsy Sarcone wrote UGH. Shanen Ebersol - that's a horrible question. Priscilla Forsyth - looks like I'll have to get my Trumpy bear back out again. Not exactly full throated support. In fact, Shannon Ebersole says she would vote for Trump and expect four more years of Biden. She just doesn't think Trump can win. This is the kind of angst you hear all over the country about a possible Trump Biden rematch. But as the GOP primary arrives in New Hampshire this week, some experts say this may be the last real chance voters have to change that outcome. My guest this week is CNN Chief National Affairs Analyst Kasie Hunt. She also hosts State of the Race on CNN International and CNN Max. We're going to talk about whether independents in New Hampshire can reshape the Republican race, and why President Joe Biden isn't even on the ballot in the Granite State. From CNN this is one thing. I'm David Rind.
David Rind
00:02:23
How was Iowa you thawed out yet?
Kasie Hunt
00:02:26
Yeah, it was good. Uh, it was freezing. I mean, I mean, freezing doesn't even capture it. It was, like, otherworldly, but it was good.
David Rind
00:02:32
So, Kasie, we're talking on Thursday, and we've had a few days to dig into some of the data around former President Donald Trump's huge win in Iowa. But just big picture. How would you describe this race now as it heads into New Hampshire?
Kasie Hunt
00:02:46
You know, David, this race is basically, I think, what we had expected all the way along, which is that Donald Trump is just an incredibly dominant frontrunner position.
Former President Donald Trump
00:02:56
They put on Nikki Haley. She came in third, a distant third, like I mean a distant third. And they put on Ron Desanctimonious, who came in a boring second.
Kasie Hunt
00:03:06
And taking him on in the context of the Republican Party, especially a Republican Party that's lost Americans, your job is even harder than it ever was.
Former President Donald Trump
00:03:15
So even though we're leading by a lot, you have to go out and vote. You just have to do it. If it's cold, if it's hot, I don't care what the hell it is, you have to go out and vote, okay?
Kasie Hunt
00:03:23
And just it also helps explain why we're heading where we're heading in New Hampshire, where people who are undeclared can vote in the Republican primary. That's different from a lot of the rest of the contests going forward. And that's what you're seeing Nikki Haley really try to do here.
David Rind
00:03:37
So the idea is like these people who are not registered Republicans, they may even be, you know, vote for Democrats normally, but they can kind of come to the polls and say, hey, Nikki Haley, it's looking good. That's the strategy here.
Kasie Hunt
00:03:49
It's a big part of the strategy. And, you know, in New Hampshire in particular, undeclared voters are the biggest group of voters, more than than people who are actually registered with a party. It's sort of part of their very proud tradition as the first in the nation primary. And I talked to Dave Carney, he's a strategist up in New Hampshire who's been working on races there for years and years and has always been one of my go to sources to kind of figure out what's really going on on the ground there.
Dave Carney
00:04:16
Well, Trump has a real organization, a grassroots organization there doing block walking with volunteers. They're doing local phone banks around the state.
Kasie Hunt
00:04:25
And there is an acknowledgment there that the people who support Trump in New Hampshire, there's the same sense of fervent support there among those people, among his people, as elsewhere.
Dave Carney
00:04:35
There's a neighbor of mine that has a gigantic banner nailed to the second floor of his house. People have painted four by eight on plywood, you know, on their driveway. So I just think the energy is with Trump.
Kasie Hunt
00:04:48
The way Carney put it was to say Trump's got people's yards and the other guys have got the right of way, right? Their campaigns have to stick signs in places that, you know, don't belong to somebody else. But there are plenty of people who are willing to put Donald Trump's name up in their yards. Now, the question is, and this is always it's one of the interesting things. There isn't a race on the Democratic side, right? President Biden is an incumbent president.
David Rind
00:05:10
I want to get to that.
Kasie Hunt
00:05:12
But what that means is that there's less pressure for voters who are undeclared, who maybe usually vote for Democrats to play in that primary. And so there's sort of an expectation that they'll be more willing to, because New Hampshire voters are honestly so engaged and interested in participating in the process, they know that they'll make a bigger difference if they vote in the Republican primary. And honestly, whether or not Nikki Haley is able to come close or even win New Hampshire is going to depend entirely on those undeclared voters.
David Rind
00:05:37
Is Ron DeSantis really conceding the state? Like, what is his plan?
Kasie Hunt
00:05:42
Well, you know, you'll remember President Biden actually pulled stakes up out of New Hampshire back in 2020 on his path to the nomination because he decided it wasn't the place for him to be. So this isn't the first time that something like this has happened.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis
00:05:55
In the state. Call for you. Hear of delegates I'm picking. I want to pick up delegates. Everyone that goes out and votes for me, he's gonna help me get delegates. And that's what we want to do.
Kasie Hunt
00:06:04
And in the context of these primaries being an expectations game, sometimes it can be helpful because it makes it easy on the back end when you lose and they know that they're going to lose. To be able to say, well, we weren't really trying anyway. Of course we lost. You always want to think about these races in terms of how the candidates relate directly to each other.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis
00:06:21
I think her record is not one that conservatives trust. She's cave. She's focusing all of the donors issues, kind of the corporatism that doesn't work. So the question is just want if you want an alternative to Trump, you know, I'm the only one that's going to be able to get votes, uh, from core Republicans and conservatives. And then, folks.
Kasie Hunt
00:06:39
It was right under the surface in the latest CNN debate where Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis got to stand on the stage together. There is no love lost between those two.
Nikki Haley
00:06:47
He's closer to zero than he is to me. I mean, he's invisible in New Hampshire. He's just invisible in South Carolina. We're focused on Trump. That's the key. We were focused on DeSantis in Iowa. We're no longer focused on him. It's Trump in New Hampshire and Trump in South Carolina.
Kasie Hunt
00:07:01
And South Carolina. Is Nikki Haley's home state. All right. So by going down there and kind of camping out, I think the DeSantis people are like, wow, we got a better shot at inching that number up. At the very least, we'll poke Haley a little bit. And I think they enjoy that a little bit.
David Rind
00:07:14
So then what would a Nikki Haley performance on Tuesday have to look like to demonstrably change the contours? Of this race.
Kasie Hunt
00:07:24
There's a real sense that Nikki Haley has to outright win New Hampshire.
Nikki Haley
00:07:32
I mean, Trump says things Americans aren't stupid to just believe what he says. The reality is, who lost the house for us? Who lost the Senate? Who lost the white House, Donald Trump, Donald Trump, Donald Trump. Nikki Haley will win every single one of those back for us. I've proven that.
Kasie Hunt
00:07:48
So. And if she doesn't, then it becomes entirely clear that Donald Trump is going to basically go most likely unbeaten through the rest of the string of primaries, because.
David Rind
00:07:58
That's ballgame.
Kasie Hunt
00:07:59
If she can't beat him in New Hampshire, where is she going to beat him? I don't see any place on the map.
David Rind
00:08:10
So can you explain this Democratic primary and how it's going to work here? Because there's been like a lot of changes and there's another guy running, right. Like what's going on?
Kasie Hunt
00:08:19
Yeah. So it's a little bit of a conundrum for Democrats. This is has to do with the Democratic Party itself. Each party sets their primary process up. They decide the order in which states are allowed to go. They determine how the delegates are counted to select their nominees. And after the 2020 election, Joe Biden didn't do very well in New Hampshire. It's not a friendly state for him. South Carolina handed him the nomination, and many Democrats believe that the demographic makeup, in particular of South Carolina, is something that reflects the party, reflects the country in a way that the very, very white demographics of Iowa and New Hampshire just do not. And so they first of all, they got rid of the Iowa caucuses as the first up. And Iowa didn't really protest. They had a really disastrous, honestly counting experience back in 2020.
David Rind
00:09:04
I still have PTSD from that.
Kasie Hunt
00:09:05
I know I remember sitting there for hours thinking, what are we going to learn anything? And slowly realizing that the probably nothing by the end of the night was going to come. So I don't think there was a lot of objection to moving Iowa, but New Hampshire has been a different story. New Hampshire is very, very proud of their role in the primary process.
Kasie Hunt
00:09:21
Why did you start your campaign in New Hampshire?
Dean Phillips
00:09:23
It's where presidential campaigns have started for 103 years. And there's a beautiful history here. But I found in New Hampshire, which is so remarkable, is the civic engagement that I really don't see the same all around the country, people who take this so seriously.
Kasie Hunt
00:09:37
They've been I was up there earlier this year talking to, um, Dean Phillips, the candidate at the congressman who's running against Biden in the Democratic primary, and also to Democrats who worked in the state for years and years. And they are very proud of the ways that they believe that even though their demographics are what they are, they feel they contributed to diversity in the party, including around Hillary Clinton, for example. But for New Hampshire, they're holding on to this process, and they have put themselves first anyway, even though it's breaking party rules. And it means that they won't get any delegates at the convention. But it also means that the president has decided or did decide that he's going to follow the DNC rules. So he is not on the ballot in New Hampshire.
David Rind
00:10:18
Wow. So when voters go up, Joe Biden will not be a possible name to check.
Kasie Hunt
00:10:22
You will not be able to check a box next to the name Joe Biden. If you are a Democrat voting in New Hampshire, it's not going to exist. The only boxes you'll see are going to be for Dean Phillips, Marianne Williamson, and there are more than likely others on the ballot whose names we don't know. They're always are. Yeah.
David Rind
00:10:37
Yeah, Vermin Supreme.
Kasie Hunt
00:10:38
Exactly. The candidate with a boot on his head. If you if you've ever seen him in in pictures. Um, so the Democrats have had to mount a write in campaign to try to make sure that, uh, something unexpected doesn't happen to the president in New Hampshire. Just because while it won't matter for the nominating contest, it certainly would be a narrative blow, especially as the president is trying to start taking on a Donald Trump. A sign of weakness against Trump, not something that's that's very welcome to Democrats. So they are nervous about it, and they're nervous about Nikki Haley because they think that, uh, her candidacy may draw those undeclared voters who otherwise might be willing to go into the Democratic primary and write down Joe Biden's name, will want to play, uh, in a competitive Republican primary instead. And it might jeopardize what's going on with them.
David Rind
00:11:21
But I guess, like, why would they be nervous? Because if his name is literally not on the ballot and he obviously has all the party infrastructure behind him to end up being the nominee, you know, come the summer. So what if Dean Phillips gets, you know, 10%, 15%, whatever it ends up being?
Kasie Hunt
00:11:37
Well, I think they're worried that it might be more than that, um, more than 10 or 15%. And, you know, I think the thing that you have to remember about politics is that there are unintended consequences for almost everything. There are things that you can't see, uh, around corners. You just never know if you let something go, it's always a risk.
Mitch Landrieu
00:11:58
I'm fairly confident, but by the time this campaign is over, American citizens will be fully informed of the incredible work that he's done and the benefit that they have to them. And as the president announced just a minute ago, just as a one metric for the people of America, since he's been president, over 14 million jobs have been created.
Kasie Hunt
00:12:15
And and I think the Biden team really knows that, especially because of the narrative that Republicans or Trump supporters are going to use against the president, which is fundamentally that he is weak. And if something unexpected were to happen in New Hampshire, that plays into that narrative, that is simply a problem for the president.
David Rind
00:12:36
It could be kind of like a vibe check as to like, what is the appetite for a Biden alternative at this point, as it's measured by real voters?
Kasie Hunt
00:12:45
Yeah. I mean, I think the reality is that neither Williamson nor Phillips fall into the category of someone that would be elevated as a strong third party candidate. Sure. But one of the things that we've been watching so very carefully are these third party groups. There's no labels who is considering running a slate that, you know, Joe Manchin has been chatted about. Um, the bigger question to Robert F Kennedy Jr, can he get on? Ballots in places where it would really impact the race. And, you know, it may be as simple as the fact that his last name is Kennedy. He obviously is an anti vaccine conspiracy theorist, but he has generated a following that we can see in the polling. And in places like Arizona, for example, where he does have a shot to get on the ballot, even a couple of points either way uh, could impact or, you know, even less than that, perhaps depending we're expecting the election between Trump and Biden, the Democrat and the Republican. Let's not totally assume Trump yet, but between the Republican and the Democrat to be just razor thin. So when the appetite is this big, bigger than we've seen, uh, since Ross Perot in 1992, uh, you just never know.
David Rind
00:13:52
Lots to pay attention to. Kasie, thanks so much.
Kasie Hunt
00:13:54
Thank you.
David Rind
00:14:03
One thing is a production of CNN audio. This episode was produced by Paola Ortiz and me, David Rind. Our senior producer is Faiz Jamil. Our supervising producer is Greg Peppers. Matt Dempsey is our production manager. Dan Dzula is our technical director. And Steve Licktieg is the executive producer of CNN Audio. We get support from Haley Thomas, Alex Manasseri, Robert Mathers, John Dianora, Leni Steinhardt, Jamus Andrest, Nichole Pesaru, and Lisa Namerow. Special thanks to Liz Brown Kaiser and Katie Hinman. Remember, you can check out the results from New Hampshire on CNN.com or at the CNN Five Things podcast wherever you listen. And we will be back next week. I'll talk to you later.